“…happiness was beyond our control.” “…true happiness was
the gift of God, to be imparted only at death and only to a chosen few.” 105 DM
Does this view of happiness imply
that God is extremely critical of us? If so do the majority of us even have a
shot at being happy as Augustine defines it?
To me this definition of happiness means that God is extremely
judgmental regarding us and this doesn’t seem to fit with all the teachings
about God loving and forgiving us. If
God is that harsh than why Jesus stress his compassion? I almost think that Augustine focused more on
the Old Testament version of God than the father figure we learned of from
Jesus. If we take Augustine’s definition
of happiness than the prospect of being happy seems very dim and
unobtainable. This leaves a rather hopeless
outlook and yet another definition that can’t satisfy most people.
I disagree, I feel that Augustine is speaking from the view of a teacher. Every teacher says that you have to study days in advance to get a good grade, even you can probably just study the night before and still get a good grade. AugustineI makes it seem that the road to heaven is narrower than it actually is to encourage everyone to be the best Christian they can be.
ReplyDeleteI struggle because Augustine is still writing during the evolution and growth of Christianity. I am not sure his promise sounds any more appealing than Stoicism or Epicureanism. Taking a page from the Stoics though, it depends on how you view the "hope" for a better life. It can be a promise containing a giant carrot at the end of a stick or a it can be a tiny carrot on a really, really long stick. No one is denying the carrot and the stick it is just how far away it is and if it is worth the suffering. My two cents of course.
ReplyDeleteGuys, I really do struggle with this idea. Personally, I am a control freak. I like to be in charge and have everything in order as it pleases me. This idea of not being in control of your own happiness is quite foreign to me. The idea of having no control frankly scares me. Even more difficult is the idea that other "being” in the end decides who is happy or not. I believe we have a big say in our own happiness and our lives. I understand that this was written in a time for people who in a way needed to hear this but for me in our modern times it is a type of excuse to not even try. And by that I mean not even try to change your life or destiny and choose your own path of happiness. We have the capability to adapt and change, so why not do it? Especially, when it concerns important subjects like happiness. Like I said before I’m speaking as a person from the modern world so I am slightly harsh and maybe misunderstanding but this is my view on the subject.
ReplyDeleteDeanna,
ReplyDeleteThe struggle is real for most of us. No one wants to have their power stripped away in our modern world. What is difficult for us to understand is that some people find comfort in another having control. Think of folks who would prefer to drive vs. prefer to have someone else drive. Everyone falls into one of the camps and you can't really change them. In a world where you have no power and you struggle and suffer all the time (Augustine's) it may be liberating to give yourself up completely to the will of God. This is NOT a modern idea though and we are ingrained at the start of educations that we are responsible for our lives/success/outcomes/happiness in America. Augustine is a bitter pill to swallow for those with their hands tightly gripping the wheel. Your reaction is valid.