Who can call today his own;
He who secure within can say:
Tomorrow do thy worst, for I have lived today." (DM 71)
The Stoics and the Epicureans believed strongly that man could control fate. By 'living life to the fullest' every day, do we, in a sense, control fate? By not allowing fate to trouble is with its whimsicality, are we controlling fate, or are we simply ignoring it? Should we even make that distinction?
"Happy the man who, free from cares,
ReplyDeletelike men of old still works
his father's fields with his own oxen,
encumbered by no debt." (DM 71)
Is the best way to become happy to live with no debts and by doing simple and humbling work? A man free from cares must surely be happy.
"If the countryside was an oasis, the city was depraved" (DM 74).
ReplyDelete"As a result of envious greed few people can say that they've had a happy life, Horace observes. Gluttony, licentiousness, concupiscence, and envy. So it is that we can rarely find a man who says he has lived a happy life and who, when his time is up, contentedly leaves the world like a guest who has had his fill" (DM 71).
Although Horace and Virgil had great ideas about how the common man could achieve happiness through living a simple means in nature, clearly the Roman culture of the time refocused itself on hedonism and greed. How meaningful could the ideas of Horace really be if the culture of his day completely disregarded them?
"So it is that we can rarely find a man who says he has lived a happy life and who, when his time is up, contentedly leaves the world like a guest who has had his fill" (DM 74).
ReplyDelete"Innocent in and of themselves, these romanticized accounts of an imaginary golden age nonetheless reveal a deep dissatisfaction with the present, a period that was certainly gilded but manifestly less than golden." (DM 73)
I can't argue with Horace too much that people then (and now), with all of their excesses were still unhappy, and still wanted more, but I can argue with the concept of ANY "golden age" of happiness...because they only see the farming lifestyle of old by looking back, inevitably, it looks better than the present. That's the brain's remarkable ability to whitewash at work. My question is, do you believe there was ever a Golden Age of happiness? (Including in your own life) Were people truly better off at some point in the past, or are we just romanticizing it now, because we cannot remember the less than satisfactory details.
"Forming nature as he is formed by it, he exudes innocence, well-being, and humble gravitas" (DM 72)
ReplyDeleteHave we, in our society today, rejected the ideas of humility, innocence, and well-being as a means of attaining happiness? Have we rejected nature in order to find our own desires?
Quotes:
ReplyDelete"prompting Romans, too, to question whether all they had in Rome was enough to give them what they desired. The legacy of the Greeks was undoubtedly important in this regard, feeding a stubborn human refusal to rest content in what we have. The spectacle of excess...generating deep misgivings about the sanctity of Roman felicitas."(DM 70).
Question:
Is the rise of greed and excess among of Romans congruent with the opinion of happiness today?
Quote
ReplyDelete"Honest, hardworking, self-reliant, robust, this was the happy husbandman, the Horacian beatus vir, a solitary farmer content to work his fields and cultivate his garden with quiet dignity and honor. He draws simple, honest pleasures from simple, honest things: close friendships and warm conversation, wholesome labor and sweat, the soothing delights of nature, a drop of wine" (DM 71).
Question
Could this be the answer to our happiness today, or in our times of technological development and lifestyles is asking for a simple lifestyle too hard?