Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Caroline Post

In class today Mr. Heintz asked a question that left me rethinking a. advent and b.  how Augustine presents a  difficult and rather arduous idea of happiness. Augustine asks a lot of his listeners: to wait for happiness after death instead of enjoying earthly pleasures? We also talked about the idea of waiting and hoping that you are virtuous enough to achieve this after-life of happiness. Its difficult, yes, but is it not what Christians are called to do? We are told that this world is temporary but why is it so hard to accept that there is happiness waiting on the other side of this life? I said in class that happiness on earth and happiness in death are two completely different things. However, now i'm not so sure. A firm believer in the virtue guiding us to happiness, does that imply that virtue in this world can guide us to happiness that can in turn guide us to happiness in death? Essentially, i have adhered to the basic belief of Thomas Aquinas. Augustine's life long advent is not something that interests me. This generation, any generation, would have a hard time coming to grips with a life of suffering for a life of wonder when we don't know what to expect. "How will we know that when we die we will have happiness for eternity?" Its an age old question that comments on faith. Faith in the sense that we SHOULD believe everything we are told, but it is still a concept that we have trouble wrapping our heads around. I cant imagine that every christian has come into contact with doubt. Do we change our idea of how happiness can be achieved to fit our lifestyles?

4 comments:

  1. I'm having trouble equating life-long struggles with life-long Advent. To me, Advent has never been a time of suffering or sadness or struggles; rather, it's been a time of hope. Happiness that Jesus was born into this world, and hope that Jesus will indeed come again. Yes, Advent is a time of waiting, and your life is a time of waiting, but I don't consider waiting a negative thing. Waiting helps you to grow as a person, and that is what allows you to have this legitimate hope that you will enter the Kingdom of Heaven and Eternal Happiness.

    And as for the question of faith and about how can we know that we will live in eternal happiness when we die, no one can answer that, obviously. But that's the beauty of faith. It's taking these truths that Jesus left for us 2000 years ago, and full-heartedly believing them, even if you can't exactly figure out what He meant. But just because you can't figure out what He meant, doesn't mean that it's wrong or that you are following blindly. Some things aren't meant to be fully understood in our human mind's capacity, but if we truly try to understand and truly try to live out the morals that Jesus left for us, we can believe and hope that we will live in eternal happiness and THEN we will be able to wrap our minds around everything that we so eagerly and truthfully followed in this life.

    ReplyDelete
  2. These are good ideas and thoughts.

    Augustine is writing when everyone is already suffering. For us it is a question of "will" we suffer or "when," but in the 4th century nearly all are suffering. This is an appeal to those folks. This is the challenge of viewing him in the 21st century. We don't suffer en masse in the same way early Christians did.

    Andrea, is waiting fun? Probably not. Even if we know it is good for us it doesn't mean we like it (dentist, shots, etc.). I made the connection with advent and it may have been a stretch as I was trying to ground the prayer service in our discussion. Advent is far from negative and I may have characterized it that way albeit unintentionally and inaccurately.

    **"Some things aren't meant to be fully understood in our human mind's capacity," -- maybe like happiness???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that waiting isn't necessarily fun, but definitely not a negative thing. Waiting allows for personal growth, so, like Myles says below, you can prepare yourself, strengthen yourself, and also provide yourself with the confidence to take on the future.

      Delete
  3. "In agreement with Andrea, I do not think of Advent as a life long struggle. I think of Advent as the preparation for Happiness. When you prepare for an athletic contest you don't prepare by suffering and struggling but instead you prepare by strengthening your skills and faith to provide yourself with confidence that you will accomplish your goals. Waiting does have its negatives but overall I do not define it as a life long struggle."

    -from Myles.

    ReplyDelete