Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Week of December 17th Posts

Put all of your quotations, questions and responses on this thread.  When responding, reply to that individual comment and not the post as a whole.  It helps to organize the blog better.

Biochemist turned Buddhist monk Matthieu Ricard talks about happiness

Also, make sure watch this video before Tuesday's presentation by a Buddhist monk.  This will help you and make the discussion more meaningful.

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Caroline Post

In class today Mr. Heintz asked a question that left me rethinking a. advent and b.  how Augustine presents a  difficult and rather arduous idea of happiness. Augustine asks a lot of his listeners: to wait for happiness after death instead of enjoying earthly pleasures? We also talked about the idea of waiting and hoping that you are virtuous enough to achieve this after-life of happiness. Its difficult, yes, but is it not what Christians are called to do? We are told that this world is temporary but why is it so hard to accept that there is happiness waiting on the other side of this life? I said in class that happiness on earth and happiness in death are two completely different things. However, now i'm not so sure. A firm believer in the virtue guiding us to happiness, does that imply that virtue in this world can guide us to happiness that can in turn guide us to happiness in death? Essentially, i have adhered to the basic belief of Thomas Aquinas. Augustine's life long advent is not something that interests me. This generation, any generation, would have a hard time coming to grips with a life of suffering for a life of wonder when we don't know what to expect. "How will we know that when we die we will have happiness for eternity?" Its an age old question that comments on faith. Faith in the sense that we SHOULD believe everything we are told, but it is still a concept that we have trouble wrapping our heads around. I cant imagine that every christian has come into contact with doubt. Do we change our idea of how happiness can be achieved to fit our lifestyles?

Monday, December 10, 2012

Mavity quote/question

"As Augustine emphasized again and again, true happiness was "the gift of God," to be imparted only at death and only to a chosen few."(McMahon 105)

I wanted to return to what we were discussing at the end of class today. Do you really think Augustine's theory is applicable today? (That is without forcing our own modern interperations on it) What I mean is, how can one really feel anymore happy when there is only a CHANCE, even if they live virtuously that they will be one of "God's Chosen Few." Sure, having that possibility could offer some hope, but I have a hard time feeling like that theory works too well at even offering a "secondary happiness" in today's age. Andrea argued that we should just count on him being a merciful God...but Augustine makes no reference to mercy here. Keep in mind, for all of the New Testament focus on love and forgiveness, this is the same God who literally wiped out the entire world in the Old Testament, banished Adam and Eve for their first offense, punished the ENTIRE egyptian culture (many who whom were not Israelite slave owners) just to get the attention of the king, required blood sacrifices (of animals...but still). It just brings the whole mercy thing into question if that's what we would be basing all of our trust in the theory's usefulness on...

So yeah...just thinking. What do you guys think?

122-133

"some partial happiness can be achieved in this life"(DM 130)

"Human nature is not so completely corrupted by sin as to be totally lacking in natural goodness"(DM 131)

Is Aquinas countering the idea brought up in class that humans can not be happy because we    are disconnected from God?

I feel that he is saying that because we are not corrupted, we are still able to have a relationship with God. Our life is a "healing proccess" that builds us closer to God and happiness.

Sunday, December 9, 2012

pgs 95-107



“…happiness was beyond our control.” “…true happiness was the gift of God, to be imparted only at death and only to a chosen few.” 105 DM

Does this view of happiness imply that God is extremely critical of us? If so do the majority of us even have a shot at being happy as Augustine defines it?

To me this definition of happiness means that God is extremely judgmental regarding us and this doesn’t seem to fit with all the teachings about God loving and forgiving us.  If God is that harsh than why Jesus stress his compassion?  I almost think that Augustine focused more on the Old Testament version of God than the father figure we learned of from Jesus.  If we take Augustine’s definition of happiness than the prospect of being happy seems very dim and unobtainable.  This leaves a rather hopeless outlook and yet another definition that can’t satisfy most people.