Thursday, February 6, 2014

Post #6 - Presentations, Frankl and Hegel

Put em up here!

56 comments:

  1. Follow the world's call. That is basically what Frankl's policy was. Does this really bring us happiness though. If the world calls to shovel animal feces, and we don't enjoy doing so... is it really happiness? Are we really becoming happy? Maybe what he is trying to say is that the world is calling us to do things and, regardless of what they are, the feeling that we are doing what we are needed to do in this world should be fulfilling. Could we really just be living life to fit in no matter what we are called to do?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think this is a case of "wuwei." Go with what life gives you. You have some control, but find meaning in what you currently have. You can swim with the current and still get to the other side but if you fight it, you will be exhausted from the struggle and may end up drowning.

      Delete
  2. Mr. Donahue said Hegel thought of happiness as "the maximum fulfillment of our desires and inclinations". Although Hegel was never recorded as successfully achieving happiness he most likely experienced joy multiple times. Could his deduction that ultimate happiness is the satisfaction of all needs be drawn form the multiplicative power of all needs being fulfilled?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think you're asking if Hegel thought happiness was found in the multiplication of his individual joys once they were all achieved. But Mr. Donahue never discussed joy- he said that fulfilling individual desires put us on "the path to happiness"- and I'm just curious if the path to happiness even "counted" as happiness. If you couldn't fully achieve all of your desires, could you fully achieve what Hegel wanted? I'm just not sure. I was mostly confused by the idea that all of your desires and inclinations had to be met to reach true happiness-- there wasn't a partial or secondary step that could be met, just a transitory phase that people went through.

      Delete
  3. I have a question about Hegel. So Mr. Donahue said that Hegel believed in a universal happiness in all of us correct? That happiness is a concept we all hold within us? I am not quite sure what he meant by that. Did he mean that happiness is something we will always strive for and not experience? A concept, something we cannot ever have or experience? Just need some clarification.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was kind of confused on that too, but I think he meant that the potential for happiness exists in all of us, just everyone utilizes that potential to different degrees and in different ways.

      Delete
    2. He seemed to flake out when confronted with the fact that Hegel's theory was not air tight. It was interesting to see him struggle with the fact that maybe... maybe if something cannot be proven stable... then it cannot be a theory and is instead''() a musing.

      Delete
    3. My understanding (I only know what you saw) is that Hegel believes a "concept of happiness" is inside all of us. Happiness is not an experience of doing something, but it is a "concept" that lives inside us. Think of it as a parasite of the mind. It is internal and inside all of us (that is the universal). The concept says the "maximization of satisfied pleasures and inclinations is happiness." Hegel's maximization just happens to be subjugation to the state.

      My gut says, just my opinion, that we can agree that happiness could be conceptual and not a specific entity or thing outside of us. I like that to a certain. However, I feel the class was learning toward each of our concepts being unique.

      Delete
  4. Frankl said that me must all listen to the world and let it tell us what we are meant to do. A vocational calling of sorts. But my question is what if we don't ever listen, but simply do what we want? If we pursue what we believe to be something that will bring us happiness...well, what happens if we get it? If we become happy doing something other than what the world supposedly want from us? Or is that answering the question? I guess technically you could say if we do something and it makes us happy that unconsciously listened to the world? I don't know.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You either

      A. answered your own question

      or

      B. will never be happy.

      Delete
    2. Wow you're right. I guess we'll just have to see.

      Delete
  5. In today's lecture, Mr. Donahue spent a lot of time asking us what happiness is. He said that we all claimed that we are happy, yet at the same time we cannot explain what is. He then explained this phenomenon by saying that "Happiness is a concept based off of feelings that we cannot explain". He continued to say that since happiness is a concept it is not an actual experience. Does that mean that happiness is not obtainable here on earth and it is just something we are wishing for but can never really have? If this is true, then can happiness be obtained in the afterlife, or is that all just a concept too?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No. I think he was calling us out for not having an answer. Hegel had an answer -- the maximization of satisfied pleasures and inclinations. You can have that in the present.

      Delete
    2. Just because we can't explain it doesn't mean that it doesn't exist. I think he was talking about how happiness is not something that you can easily express in words. Also, I think he was just trying to get us to say the words he wanted to hear. He was trying to get us to explain Hegel instead of him having to do all the work. It is probably just the way that he presented the material that was a bit confusing.

      Delete
  6. I couldn't help but notice as (mostly) everyone was presenting their personal music pieces, they usually said something about how their song made them feel calm. Calmness is obviously a positive emotion, but it's not really happiness. Happiness is beyond that, I think. Happiness is better than feeling calm; it's more intense and even more positive. However, we go to a school where we have to work our butts off to get good grades, as well as participate in many extracurriculars and a lot more. There definitely seems to be an increased amount of stress (especially about school) in teens today than in teens a few decades, or even years ago. We live in a crazy, high-pressure society, and I wonder if because of that we don't just settle for calmness.

    Are we so stressed out that the things that make us happy are just things that temporarily relieve us from the stress and make us feel calm. Moreover, has our high-pressure society changed our definition of happiness?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Could this high pressure society be breeding a generation that relies on "extremely low pressure" situations for calmness? Could this fact be why we see such extreme variations in Marist students from their daily lives to their school lives. For me at least, I don't think people know me unless they have seen me carefree and calm.

      Delete
    2. What is ataraxia but a mental calmness? Buddhists aim for "calm seas" (we will see it in a TED talk) called equanimity. I think you are nailing it. True happiness isn't a temporary high but a long term general state of being.

      Delete
  7. "It did not really matter what we expected from life, but rather what life expected from us."
    -Viktor Frankl

    I love Viktor Frankl's philosophy of the meaning of life and happiness. It's one of my favorite's that we have heard so far. It just makes sense that the meaning of life cannot be fueled by one's own desires, but instead by what one is really called to do. If you have the opportunity to do something good, you should take that opportunity. You owe that to life, to others, and to yourself. Because really, doing what you're supposed to do in life is the meaning of your life, and I think doing what you're meant to do will bring you happiness.
    I kind of feel like this philosophy builds off of Christianity. Christianity is so humbling and all about service to others and God. Frankl's philosophy is also humbling, but it's more focused on what one is really meant to do. It's more individualized than Christianity is.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Is that problematic that Christianity isn't more individualized? Isn't community a big source of happiness and comfort for most? A bit of foreshadowing...it is!

      Delete
    2. Just as Christianity is lacking some amount of specifics for the individual, Frankl is lacking specifics for the community.
      Frankl wants us to ask ourselves "daily and hourly" what life wants from us, whereas Christian philosophy simply calls for general service to others. Christianity has a large emphasis on community, and Frankl is more focused on what each person is individually meant to do. Community as well as individualization are important, and both philosophies include these ideas, but each is lacking one to some degree. I would not say this is necessarily problematic, it just makes them different.

      Delete
  8. "It does not matter what we expected from life, but rather what life expected from us." - Victor Frankel. To me this idea seems a lot like the Hindu concept of Dharma. Dharma is basically the role that one was born to play in life. For example if a person was born to be a soldier he/she could not decide to be a politician just because they wanted to do that instead. If they did so they would never find meaning for their life and never reach Nirvana, which is eternal bliss. Frankel's idea is that life sets out certain things and puts people in certain situations that need to be reacted to in the right way. The right way to react to these situations and then act on them, is dictated by what life, or your Dharma, expects of you. By reacting and acting on life in the way that life intends for you to do so you will find meaning. But does meaning equal happiness? Victor Frankel would say yes. If you as truly doing what life intends for you to be doing then you will find happiness in doing that thing, just like how if you live your life in accordance to your personal Dhrama you will be at peace, find meaning, and reach Nirvana/happiness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    2. But at the same time, Dharma is sometimes oppressive. (Or at least it used to be, especially for women and the lower class.) Dharma means that you can't do the things you want, love the people you want, or act the way you want- just because of the way you were born. I'm not sure that Frankl would agree with that concept so much as he would advocate for people to accept what's coming to them naturally- not force themselves into standardized societal roles.

      Delete
    3. Dharma is perceived by those people as being oppressive because they would rather go against what their Dharma because they think that doing something else will make them happier here on earth. In the Hindu religion, Dharma is not a social tool meant to separate people based on their status. It is something that sets out how they need to live if they want to become closer to reaching nirvana. The idea is that if they follow their Dharma correctly they will reach nirvana and be happier than if they go against it. Dharma is not supposed to be what you want during life but instead something that gets you to what you actually desire, eternal bliss. This does fall in line with Frankl's idea because doing what life expects out of you will bring you greater meaning and happiness than doing what you want to do.

      Delete
  9. Mr. Murphy explained how Viktor Frankl's view on the what drives people is a search for meaning. He said that Frankl's views rivaled those another psychologist who thought the driving force of life was power or man's search for it. In a way are these two ideas the same? I always thought of power as being all-knowing in a way. Knowledge is power and to be powerful, a person must have a greater knowledge of things than others. So, in a way, would Frankl's search for a meaning/knowledge and a search for power be the same thing?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I like your idea on the relationship between knowledge and power, and then meaning and power. I think that they do overlap a little bit but I think that Frankl would have disagreed because the other philosopher was talking more about having power over other, not just the power of having knowledge of your meaning in life.

      Delete
    2. I tend to agree with you that knowledge is power, but the again that could be subjective. Some have no interest in being smart or having knowledge. Cleaning public restrooms may make them happy, and may be their "calling, and that involves little to no knowledge about anything.

      Delete
    3. I think the knowledge this psychologist was talking about is not really the knowledge we think of, but rather knowing what our calling is or the "questions" life is asking of us. So yes, the knowledge that he is talking of would probably bring happiness. If we know what the questions are, then we can know how to find the meaning in our life, and therefore be happy.

      Delete
  10. I agreed with about half of Hegel's views. I think that happiness is conceptual but also subjective. For instance the subjugation of a person to the state might be Hegel's ideal thought of ultimate happiness, but it's not for everyone. On the conceptual note, I think that the body is able to experience pleasure and things of that nature, but it can't feel. Only the mind can do that. If the body determined happiness, then it would be easier to find a universal source of happiness. All bodies enjoy being comfortable; therefore, relaxing in a fluffy chair might be the universal source of happiness. It is only when you add the mind into the equation that a universal happiness is unattainable. The mind adds emotions and that sense of happiness, and it doesn't always add the same emotions to everything. The relationships between things and emotions is different for every person and that is why there cannot be a universal source of happiness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you, and I think that the idea that the mind conceptualizes individual happiness supports Descartes and, by extension, Hegel who decided that the mind and body were separate and that the mind itself was superior. The mind can actually feel, as opposed to simply experience through the senses as the body does, and once the mind becomes involved, then happiness, as you said, becomes more complicated and individualistic.

      Delete
  11. Mr. Murphy's presentation about Victor Frankl focused on how we are supposed to respond to what life asks of us. But sometimes, life asks a lot of us- and I for one, can't always respond completely. Are we failing at finding "meaning" to our life when we reach rock bottom?
    For example, at a school like Marist, we are asked constantly and consistently for everything we can possibly provide to be put towards schoolwork. But we're also being asked for extracurricular time, for social relationships, to get jobs and to find internships and to plan a future.
    We manage pretty well, for sure, but sometimes we fall short. Sometimes we miss an assignment or fail a test or piss people off or don't get the interview we wanted.
    I'm mostly playing devil's advocate here, but sometimes what life asks of us is a little much? Are we failing when we reprioritize? Are we not finding sufficient meaning when we can't complete everything or when we find some personal time amidst the other demands that are being asked of us? Are we not living correctly when we can't do everything all at once?
    I think we can still be happy and find meaning in our lives without responding to every single individual thing we're supposed to do. What do you think?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Frankl is not talking about getting what we want or our priorities at all. Our desires will not give us meaning. What will give us meaning is doing what life desires of us. He's talking less about doing well in everything, and more about being a good person. I think life is probably asking us more often to do what is right than to do well on every assignment or nail every interview. That's more about what we are asking of ourselves and what others are asking of us. Granted, it can become difficult to always do the right thing if life is asking you to respond to a lot, but if you don't always succeed, I think there's some lee-way in there. It's less about succeeding, and more about trying. So cheesy, but we just have to do our best!

      Delete
    2. Right, I quantitatively agree with Gracie. I think that what life is asking us to do and what, say, Marist is expecting us to do are two completely separate ideas. And I don't think life asks us to do anything for which we cannot meet its "expectations" whereas, to continue the analogy, Marist's expectations are so high that we often feel as though we fall short. Frankl says "the meaning of life is to give life meaning" and if that's what life is asking of us, then that's a pretty open ended assignment on which I'm sure we can grade ourselves.

      Delete
  12. for murphy and Frankl it seemed more so ot be in line with stoicism and listening to the world around you to find the happiness in your life. This view is one that i relatively agree with yet Hegel's maximum fulfillment of desires it goes well with this idea. Basically, if you have few desires then you can maximize the amount of happiness that you can achieve. I feel that these two philosophies would complement each other well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can see the connection you are making between the two. I think that Hegel is more taking your desires in strides. He is saying if you accomplish one of your goals, it will keep you along the track to happiness. The other is more of elimination desires so you can have a better ratio. So, in one you keep all your desires but achieve the in steps, and the other you get rid of the less important ones to improve your ratio.

      Delete
  13. Finally, a simple approach to happiness. Mr. Murphy's lecture was great because it brings in a concept of happiness that many philosophers haven't talked about - the meaning of life. I completely agree that people must have some sort of thing to live for in order to be happy; the meaning we find in the things we do gives us a reason to be happy.
    His explanation was simple, but it got confusing when he starting talking about the questions life asks of us. I like the idea, but I don't get how we are supposed to know what kinds of questions life is asking. How do we know the questions? Life isn't exactly a person that we can just talk to and ask. I see it more as finding things that we feel obligated to do or feel a calling to as the questions.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with Sydney. I think it is hard to distinguish between what we are being called to do and what we want to do. if we want to achieve something in life, is it necessary to stop and ponder whether it is what life is asking of us? Personally, i don't know if i would like to believe that life is calling me to do something that i don't want to do. It is at least easier for me to find meaning in my life through doing things that i want to do.

      Delete
  14. I agree Sydney. He asked so many questions about life its hard to distinguish anything. The questions we could ask ourselves about every tiny aspect of our lives are endless. To me, it almost seemed like micromanaging. I like the idea, but I think it could be widdled down to some definite broad questions that apply to all.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I really liked what Mr. Murphy had to say about finding the meaning of life. I think it makes sense to try to find what life is calling you to do instead of trying to be in control of every aspect of your life. This kind of ties into my presentation because i wrote about the song "Positive Mind" that tells you to start living with a positive mind because you can't expect life to always make you happy. One of the lyrics to "Positive Mind" is "positivity through responsibility" which also ties in with Mr. Murphy's presentation. He said that you need to be responsible in order to find and do what life needs you to do.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I really liked Mr. Murphy's presentations on Frankl. I like more than anything the idea of responding to what life asks and gives us. Everyone's desires and perspectives are different, and therefore their means to reaching happiness vary. But Frankl provides a simple and clear way for everyone to reach it which is: responding to what life asks of us. I translated this to mean that one needs to make the most out of whatever life throws at him or her or simply have a positive outlook on life. I've always thought it was interesting that people found such joy and happiness out of things that I've never associated those emotions with before. And in this way, their perspective and outlook allowed them to view their situation as better and more pleasant. If we always have this mindset, life would seem happier as a result. I'm a strong believer that our mind controls our emotions and actions and ultimately our happiness. Frankl's theory on happiness matches up with mine pretty closely. By doing what you are meant to do in life, you are fulfilling your life and finding meaning and a purpose for your life. You are literally finding the meaning of your individual life by responding to what life brings and asks of you, regardless of what your thoughts and desires for the future may consist of.

    ReplyDelete
  18. My fellow Americans, ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.-John F Kennedy
    very similar to Frankles idea of not depending on life to hand you something, to go out an get it yourself. i enjoy this idea of self action. from its creation at the hands of Frankle, i feel like the message has been carried on through selfhelp books and JFKs speech. my question is, what f we dont like what the world is calling us to do?
    if or true purpose was to be a janitor at an elementary school, and we knew it and it would make us happy, but we didnt want to become one. i think it would make us unable to find happyness for a time, but our idea of happinness could change which would then change our calling.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When I read the question, I immediately thought of many stories of how a priest chose to become a priest. They would often say that they were called to serve God, but they didn't think that the priestly life was for them. However, they felt like they were being called and pushed back towards God.

      Delete
  19. What is it about music that evokes emotion? In our presentations, almost everyone presented a song of choice that made them happy and, on the flip side, I think everyone could name a handful of songs that can make them cry with just one listen. Why do songs more so than architecture or literature or film make us feel so much? I mean, a song with lyrics is not much more than a poem set to a tune, so why doesn't poetry evoke as much emotion? I loved what Will brought up about how major and minor keys create different emotions in people due to the natural vs. synthetic tones, but I'm sure there's more to it than that. What is it about notes and melodies that make people connect and reflect so much? And why is there no universally "happy" note or melody? Which brings us back to a large question in many of our discussions: Is happiness something that can be defined as a universal?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't think there is any type of music that can set a universal standard for happiness. Just like with many other aspects of life, people have different tastes in music. What someone presented for their personal piece as a song that makes them happy, I could think it's a terrible song and it makes me unhappy to listen to it. If someone is listening to a piece of music for the first time, I do think the notes and melodies used make a huge difference on whether or not someone likes that song, but I believe it is the memories and the emotions we associate with our favorite songs that make us so happy.

      Delete
  20. Personally, Hegel's entire philosophy is vague and confusing. The only thing I understood from Mr. Donahue's presentation is that we all have a concept of happiness inside of us. Is that all there is to it? Does all of Hegel's philosophy boil down to this?

    ReplyDelete
  21. "Individual desires would still be shaped by social forces, but now each member of the community would truly want just what was of genuine service to the community as a whole." (page 372).
    Is it possible for a socialist state to exist, because that is what is being described in the quote above. No, it is not. Ideas such as communism and other forms of extreme socialism look good on paper, but in practice it has been proven unsuccessful. I believe no matter how many good hearted people are out there that only want what is best for everyone around them, there are always those that are willing to corrupt the system for their own personal gain.

    ReplyDelete
  22. paraphrased from Mr. Donahue's/Hegel's ideas: "Happiness occurs through the fulfillment of desire."

    In my opinion, this is a very valid statement. It goes alongside the principle of fractional happiness. Personally, whenever I achieve one of my desires, I become very happy. However, I also believe that happiness can come from the fulfillment of other peoples desires. After helping others, I can also become happy from their joy and satisfaction..

    ReplyDelete
  23. Does truth have to occur through the senses?

    In his presentation, Mr. Donahue stated that truth occurs through the senses in correspondence with the outside and the inside of the mind. I believe that some truths can occur from purely the mind and not from the senses. For example, I have never physically seen God, yet I have faith. Some things including our virtues can also occur through the disposition we are born with and not taught through the senses.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I really liked Mr. Murphy's lecture on Frankl. Frankl's ideas for finding meaning (finding meaning in each moment rather than in a lifetime) are really attractive, and they do seem to make living life easier. It's like when you're in a race that you aren't too excited about. If your goal is to get to the finish line, it will seem like you aren't making any progress. But, if your goal is to get to the next telephone pole, then the next, then the next, you can actually see your progress, making the race much more endurable.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I'm a bit confused by Bagel's "unhappy consciousness." Pgs. 368-369 talk about how Christianity set up a wall between the "sacred and profane." The Christians "[strive] for the unchanging God," but they run up "continually against the changing needs and limitations of the material world." So, is it called unhappy consciousness because the Christians are always aware that they can't reach their God (Happiness), because they don't adapt to their physical world? Christianity seems like a very stubborn religion, unwilling to change with the times and staying with ideas relevant sometimes only hundreds of years ago. It seems like pre-reformation Christianity tried the same thing over and over again to reach Heaven, but it kept on running into the same limitations of the changed world. Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again hoping for a different result, so would Bagel think of Christians as insane?

    ReplyDelete
  26. "The meaning of life is to give life meaning" --Frankl

    Nearly diametrically opposed to Nietsche's view, Frankl tells us that happiness can be found in discovering meaning in life, no matter what that meaning is. When thinking about this on a deeper level, I personally don't know whether there is a meaning to life or to my life specifically. At least not yet. So I had to ask myself whether Nietzsche had it right after all. I came to the conclusion that being right is less important than being happy. Though life may be futile and meaningless and hollow, if we can find some sort of meaning, even if that meaning is a delusion of grandeur, then we can be happy. I'm not sure whether Frankl has solved it with his quip about the meaning of life, but at least he's given us an idea for a path to happiness. Nietzsche may be right, but his being right doesn't make us happy. Finding happiness doesn't have to be synonymous to finding truth. I think that belief is where this optimism comes from.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I loved Mr. Murphy's lecture. The video he showed us was really touching and I really related to Frankl's views. I do things to find meaning, I always complain about doing things if there's no reason for it, I always have. For me, there has to be some bigger purpose behind it. I like how he thought that we should search for meaning in every situation, even if it's absolutely miserable, because I think that's inevitable. I believe that while suffering is unavoidable and isn't enjoyable, it has a purpose and we have to find it's meaning in the grand scheme of our lives.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Mr. Murphy talked heavily about there being a reason behind every action and a reason each person exists. While there are certain people in my classes that I believe strongly challenge this theory, for the most part, I agree. Frankl seems to stem off of Aristotle's belief that everyone is here for a given purpose and it's up to us to determine what it is. According to Mr. Murphy, Frankl took it one step further and said we could gain happiness by discovering that purpose and maximizing its use. I think everything in this universe is designed to help something else. When I was younger, I asked my mom why obnoxious flies even existed. She told me it was to feed the frogs. This is a prime example that life can come from giving life to another.

    ReplyDelete
  29. The part that I took most from Mr. Murphy's lecture was "the meaning of life is to give life a meaning". I was really impressed by that statement, so much though that I wrote it on my hand. I think that Frankl's idea of finding the purpose of our lives is a view that a lot of people follow today. It's impossible for me to know what the one true meaning of my life is right now, because I am so young and have not experienced enough in my life yet. But I think that a large purpose of my existence is helping others, especially in the special needs community. I find happiness through helping these people, because I know that they genuinely need my help. I love knowing that they depend on me and that I enhance their life. I think that when people realize that they have a meaning in life, they generally find happiness in that. Just knowing that every person's life has a purpose can affect the way you live your life. I know that I am on earth for a reason, and by following that reason, I am also following my own path to happiness.

    ReplyDelete