Sunday, January 5, 2014

Week #3 Christianity!

How does Christianity change things? 

Are Christians just reinvented Homeric Greeks accepting suffering?

What does Jesus really say about happiness?

Look for word connections with the Greeks.

Do Augustine and Aquinas actually change things or is it more of the same?

81 comments:

  1. On page 84 Mahon argues that the book of Ecclesiastes culminates in the realization that "all human striving is pointless." In Ecc. 2:17, it states that "what is done under the sun is grievous to me; for all is vanity and a chasing after wind." Christianity introduces the idea that not only can there be no happiness without suffering, but that happiness is a direct result of suffering. One can argue that suffering in the Bible is equated to earthly life and happiness is equated to a heavenly one. Though I consider myself a Christian, I find the Bible to be supplemental rather than integral to my faith, and therefore can be critiqued extensively. I dislike what this passage says about human life. I personally don't want to be so cynical about earthly suffering. Though Christianity offers an eternal reward as a bribe to get through the ups and downs of conscious life, I don't want to wish away days knowing that "Hey, it may be bad now but someday somehow I'll make it to eternal paradise because I'm sucking it up here." That's just a stinky way to get through suffering. I'm much more inclined to subscribe to a Buddhist or even Stoic theory in which I can cut down on suffering here in this world. Instant gratification. It goes back to one of the fundamental questions of happiness: how much can we control?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You make a very good point. Worshiping suffering seems counter-intuitive to the pursuit of happiness, and sometimes I feel like Christianity was a religion intended for the blessed in the beatitudes. However, I'm almost perfectly in line with the Christian belief that perfect happiness is in Heaven. I like what Aristotle and Aquinas believed: that there are two forms of happiness; perfect happiness is controlled by God, and imperfect happiness is controlled by us. I like to think that I have SOME control over my happiness, so if I don't make it to Heaven, I will have experienced at least SOME happiness.

      You probably believe something different from me, Mr. Ditzel different from that, the Buddhist monk different from that. So, to answer your question, I guess it all boils down to a matter of opinion over what your beliefs of happiness are.

      Delete
    2. I agree with Serena's point. It seems depressing to always be focusing on something you cannot achieve until death. I think that the early Christian belief about suffering would be especially hard for people of our generation to relate to because we are so young and have so much of our lives ahead of us. It is comforting to think that we can achieve true happiness in the afterlife with no suffering, but i definitely don't want to spend my life looking forward to the day i die. I also agree with Frank's point that we are in control of imperfect happiness. We will not achieve perfect happiness until we die and therefore do not know what it is like or what it would be like. I would rather be imperfectly happy than not happy at all.

      Delete
  2. It does seem to me that Christianity caused the Happiness philosophy to come almost full circle back to the Homeric Greek view. Christians, because of the promise of eternal life, a heaven or paradise of some sort, the whole "it gets better, just stick it out until death" mentality, are supposed to accept what happens to them. In a fundamentally Christian view, suffering happens to people; it's non-negotiable and imminent. As McMahon says on 101, "On the road of life, we will always suffer thirst. Happiness, here, is not our measure." Instead of the idea of fate, though, Christians have God's plan, His will. As long as we are still looking upwards and we keep the promise of better times in the afterlife in mind, we will be happy someday. It's out of our hands, just like the ancient Greeks thought, minus, you know, a Jesus Christ to thank.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with what you're saying, but I feel like it's different because early Christianity wasn't just an acceptance of suffering, it was an embrace. Christians knew they had to suffer, but they found happiness in their suffering. The Homeric view did not include that bit, which is a very important part. Also, whereas the idea of fate may get you down, God's plan does not. Christians, I think, were happy with whatever God's will was. Again, not only accepting it, but embracing it. Greeks didn't have this relationship with fate. There wasn't much reason behind their suffering. Christians have a reason behind all of the suffering: it's because God wills it to be so, and because the promise of heaven, though it is in the distance, lies ahead.

      Delete
  3. The Christians shared the same idea with the Homeric Greeks because they accept that suffering is an essential and unavoidable part of life. However, unlike the Homeric Greeks they did not only accept it, instead the Christians embraced it. They believed that it did not matter if you suffered during your time on earth because they believed that this suffering would be outweighed by their reward in heaven. This brings me to m question. Do you think that Christians still have the same out look as they did in ancient times? If so how do you see this taking place? Personal I think that times and opinions on suffering have changed in the Christian community. I cannot say that I know of anyone who would look forward to suffering because they will be rewarded later. I do believe that Christians today would stay true to their faith if confronted, but I think that almost every Christian today would rather live a good life than be constantly suffering to get into heaven.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ryan, if I understood your question correctly, you're saying Christians in modern times don't look forward or embrace suffering as much? If my understanding is correct, I would tend you agree with you. In modern times, I believe the Christian outlook is not so much to endure suffering and accept it, but rather to try to live a moral life and live for God. Instead of simply enduring, today the common theme seems to be to "do" something about your suffering, or to live a moral life to prevent said suffering. I believe today Christianity has more human agency as far as doing something about suffering rather than just enduring and looking to the world ahead. Do you agree?

      Delete
  4. Quote: “Broadly speaking, egalitarian and, broadly speaking, communal, the early charismatic sects of Mediterranean Christendom demanded renunciation- of money, of social ties, of one’s past- in return for deep solidarity and intimate support.” (McMahon 90). Christianity in its early stages attracted people of the lower class and the outcasts of society because of its message of equality. If the primary demographic of a religion are the poor and decrepit of society, why should they focus on the avoidance of suffering and pain when it is part of the poor’s day-to-day happenings? Therefore, those who are already facing hardships are told to embrace them with the promise that if they continue to suffer, their reward is an eternity in paradise. If early Christians were told to give up their money and social ties, they readily agreed because they had little to give but much to gain.

    ReplyDelete
  5. On page 85, McMahon asks the question "For if the disaffected, the 'poor in spirit,' are really makarios, and if those who mourn are really blessed, are not the men and women who in the common view are 'sad' actually happy, and those who are treated as 'happy' actually sad?" In my opinion, this question embodies the change that Christianity begins to bring about. The Stoics and Epicureans believed that happiness was the absence of mental anguish or pain. Christians, on the other hand, taught that happiness was found basically through mental anguish and pain. Referring back to the Beatitudes, the Christians also had a different view on who exactly was happy or blessed. I assume that the Christians were the first to officially believe that those who suffer are the most blessed. It was not until our class discussion that I fully understood the Beatitudes, and how those who are suffering should rejoice because their afterlife will be unimaginably better than their current one. This leads me to my question: Is Christianity the same as it is today? Do current Christians lead similar lives to the early Christians? I think Christianity to some degree has remained the same. We have more or less the same beliefs and customs, but I think what creates the biggest difference between early and modern Christianity is those who practice it. Early Christians lived in a much more unpredictable world, and would probably be more interested in putting in the effort it took to live a Christian life. Today, people are much more independent. Our lives are much more predictable, and that sort of decreases the need or desire to have faith in God. I think that because of this, we have less Perpetuas and Felicitas in our modern world. In my opinion, people in our world today are so preoccupied with short-lived happiness that they are not interested in long-term happiness, which early Christians found through their faith.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Christianity makes happiness more of a goal that can be reached by many – even women could be happy, wow. The fact that Jesus lived a life of poverty also expanded happiness to those with less money and less education. Christianity also gave people something to hold on to and hope for: going to heaven and an end to suffering. Sure, they both believed that suffering was an inevitable part of life, but Christians at least saw a reason for their suffering, they would be rewarded in heaven. Homeric Greeks didn’t have as much of a goal rather than just an escape with symposiums, etc. For Christians, if they could get through the suffering on Earth, they could reach an ultimate reward, or escape, in heaven. Where I get confused is with the idea that early Christians believed that suffering somehow equaled happiness. I think it would make more sense that people have to go through suffering in order to truly be happy. Without knowing what it’s like to be extremely unhappy and go through so much suffering, true happiness would be less fulfilling.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I didn't really explicitly state my question, it's: Is happiness less fulfilling for those who have suffered less? The book mentions that "Christ recommends suffering's active embrace". Thinking of Christianity now, suffering is one of the last things I would think of as part of the religion. It seems strange that God would want us to suffer.

      Delete
    2. I'm guessing from this Christian perspective, it's not that God wants Christians to suffer so much as God wants us to realize and empathize with what he did for them; he suffered and died for them and if suffering is a way to realize it, then that helps. But he doesn't force the suffering upon his believers, it's a product of a broken world (tainted by original sin) that is unavoidable, so he turns it into a beneficial experience to bring followers closer to him.

      Delete
    3. I agree with what you said about Christianity opening the door for more common people such as women and the less fortunate. However, Christians didn't believe that suffering was equal with happiness. What I got out of McMahon's reading was that Christians found happiness through suffering. Suffering was simply a medium to reach happiness and this was seen as comforting to people back then, because this made people believe that their suffering and misery was worth the happiness that they would achieve in Heaven. Without suffering, happiness would be less fulfilling, and that is the whole point of finding comfort in the Christians philosophy on death. Christianity promises happiness through misery and gives people the power to choose, which in the early Christians time period of chaos was comforting.

      Going back to your other question about whether people that suffer less are less fulfilled once they reach happiness: I think that a person who has suffered less than a person who has had an extreme amount of suffering is the same. Their happiness is still equal. The person who suffers less will not have a bigger or more catastrophic experience of suffering to compare the smaller suffering to. As a result, these people will experience their small amount of suffering as huge in their lives. The people who have had a lot of suffering in their lives still view their most extreme experiences of suffering as just that: extreme. So in a way, both people see their experiences as a huge amount of suffering, and therefore, they will both reach the same level of happiness. Just because one has not had as much suffering in their life does not mean it had less of an effect on them as a person with a lot of suffering would have.

      Delete
  7. Question: Could Christianity be seen as a culmination of classical learning and thought which draws from several different Greek schools of thought, or did it develop an entirely new path to happiness? The answer one comes up with depends on how you view the Church, either from top to bottom or bottom to top. To clarify this, top to bottom means looking at the beliefs as being created by the top few officials which was then handed down to the masses of followers. Bottom to top, however, means looking at the basic adherents who may have formed their beliefs which were clarified and codified by the top officials. From top to bottom, it could be argued that Christianity is an accumulation of classical learning which drew the ideas of many Greek philosophers because the heads of the early Christian church were educated men who most likely knew of the teachings of the eminent Greek philosophers. From bottom to top, it could be argued that although it may have similarities to many Greek schools of thought, the general adherents of Christianity did not possess the knowledge or education to know the teachings of these philosophers.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Matt, that's a great question. Personally, I think early Christianity was almost a regression back into a somewhat Homeric mindset. The idea of everything is out of our control, and to simply endure suffering seems very closely related to how the ancient Greeks perceived things. Although I also think the Greeks seemed to rely more heavily on pure luck, whereas early Christians seemed to have a certain sense of surety about whether or not they would go to heaven. The Greeks seemed to be a little more content with chance, while the early Christians needed a certainty that life would be better after death. Having said this, the argument can be made that early Christianity is somewhat irrelevant compared to modern Christianity. I think modern Christianity has evolved to the point that human agency is a key component to whether or not one will go to heaven. In the ancient world, as long as one endured their earthly suffering they would go to heaven, but in modern day is seems as though people tend to want to actually DO something about their suffering, and the theme of more to live morally in order to eliminate suffering and go to heaven, rather than to simply endure. All in all, I think early Christianity is a culmination (like you said) of ancient Greek thought, but modern Christianity has evolved into a different animal altogether.... Wow that got long

      Delete
  8. Although many a times i have considered myself a christian man, the whole idea of accepting suffering as a path to reward comes off as a lazy way to progress through life. "oh well life is terrible... lets just wait it out and maybe even make it worse, in the end we will be rewarded for our toil... just not here... and the ways that you can prove that this is true are sketchy... oh well" Is christianity just a lazy way of looking at the world?

    The greeks came off as actively trying to eliminate or reduce suffering and, by proxy, earthly attachment in their life. Those who followed philosophies such as Plato and Aristotle where subscribing to a brand of thinking which tried to show how to actively improve life. If they were not trying to eliminate this suffering, the greeks where making the best of what they had. They partied like animals and tried to constantly push through the horridness of their daily existence. They balanced their cadaver-like existence with grande indulgence. They took active steps to alleviate their sadness even if only momentarily. All of this while the christians simply meandered through their path of christlike thorns with the powerful conviction that there pain was momentary and the world is just a barricade to heavenly peace. Maybe christianity didn't require as many varied changes in life, and maybe it had very little reward on earth. It doesn't matter because Christianity held the greatest defense of any religion yet, you couldn't disprove it without dying and coming back to life. Although this may be a great strength, it could also be a ferocious weakness. How on earth could one prove that what they where worshipping was real? The faith taken to justify and believe in such a huge idea as suffering for ultimate glory (especially not in this life time) must have been great. The internal struggle that humans, a race which relies heavily on its senses to determine true from false, must have experienced when trying to justify death for something supported by sparse miracles and signs must have been immense. This mental strain and internal struggle, although not for all, must have been quite great. Christianity is not lazy, it took great mental discipline just like the other beliefs at the time.

    Thoughts?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I like that. When you put it that way, like you did in the first paragraph, it does seem that Christianity is the lazy way of looking at the world. There's nothing I can do about this contentment or lack thereof that I'm feeling, all I can do is wait until the next life. Whatever will happen to me, will happen, whether that's in suffering or not. However, when you look at it like Coach Ditzel explained, and as you pointed out, it does take some work to make this life, well, not futile. If life is only a purgatory of sorts between non-existence and happiness, then why wait for death and not just make it happen? Because of this promise of secondary happiness through the beattitudes, we find purpose and (to pull the great Christian scholar in here) hope.

      Delete
    2. I would personally say that it is a lot harder because you have to have faith that that afterlife will be there and that eternal happiness is actually possible. I think it's very tempting to give in to just achieving temporary happiness in the word, but achieving eternal happiness would be a greater reward, even though it would take more effort. It may seem like a lazy view in a way- like you're just going to sit back and go through your suffering and let God figure it out. But I think that that whole idea of fate is more of a Homeric view. The Christian view isn't necessarily sitting back and letting things happen to you. It's more of choosing to go through this suffering and make a sacrifice in order to achieve an eternal happiness. And I agree, it definitely does take a lot more mental discipline. Good point.

      Delete
  9. "There is a time for everything: to weep and laugh, to mourn and dance, to love and hate. God attends to all" (McMahon 84)

    This one may be a little out there, although it is not directly associated with the primary questions above, i feel it needs discussion.

    The quote above portrays God as not just a bringer of good news, but also bad.
    We get the idea that this God was feared and loved at the same time. The perfect leadership balance of the two. This God was generous, yet also punished and allowed for terrible emotions to flow. This God was not just a wish granter and savior, but a teacher who both rewarded his students and punished them. Was it ever considered that this omni- active God was just bringing pain and suffering into the world so that ultimately we would be forced into his arms like a rabbit trap. Although there was protection in the rabbit trap and ultimately peace, we were afraid of being captured. The very pain that we hate is what drives us to think we need God and in turn his value and power grows as he controls the remedy to sadness and suffering. God holds a monopoly on your every move. If the things that God brought and brings could be manipulated by each man, there would be no need for a God. Could the early christians have started the chain reaction of being trapped as they moved responsibility for ultimate salvation to one being. Though the initial choice is somewhat empowering, the first step is all that we control. Although the choice to jump into the rabbit trap was made by the rabbit, the entrapment and results that followed were totally controlled and dependent upon the eventual extraction of the rabbit and peaceful annihilation of its tiny life spark. But don't worry, the rabbit didn't die. He went to a bunny farm to play with other happy trapped bunnies. Could the idea of this early God have been so terribly scary? Is it scary at all?
    Are you enjoying your cage?
    I am.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1. this solidifies my love-hate relationship with your metaphors. mostly on the hate side.
      2. in response to your actual question (sort of)-- it holds mentioning that according to the Christian tradition, God does not create anything bad-- only the devil does that. The devil creates the evil that hurts, tempts, and unnerves Christians and their faith. So from that perspective, God can't be playing two sides to "trap" believers; he's simply the other option when confronted with the devil.

      Delete
    2. Are you saying it was God who trapped the bunnies? Because I feel like God was the one who freed the bunnies from the cages of greed, adultery, hate, etc.

      Why are bunnies drawn into cages like this? Food. Instant gratification. No having to hunt around for carrots. In the same respect, people are drawn into physical things like money. With money, you can go into a STORE and BUY things, without having to HUNT for things.Again, instant gratification.

      Keeping with the metaphor, God was walking along one day through the forest he planted, and came across these cages (set out by poachers) with bunnies trapped inside of them. The bunnies have to accept that while they are in the cages, there’s nothing they can do, except maybe keeping themselves busy by trying to break the latch on the cage. However, the latch is welded shut, and the poor little bunnies’ paaws can’t break the welds. God’s hands, on the other hand (pun intended), ARE able to break the latch open and set the bunnies free. Once the bunnies are free from the cage, they realize there’s so much they can do! They don’t have to just play with the latch, they can play in the bushes and in the garden, and with more bunnies than they ever dreamed of playing with in the cage. This makes them truly happy. Playing with the latch only gave them a sense of false happiness.

      Delete
  10. "The first step to happiness is the step itself."- page 78
    For me I think that this is an important statement. I feel that to really obtain happiness one has to act and do. A person can not attain happiness by just sitting around waiting for happiness to be given to them. This statement relates back to the habituation of virtue proposed by Aristotle. In order to appreciate and find enjoyment/happiness in it, one must first do it. One must appreciate the process before they can obtain the result.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. You can't expect to just sit around and have things work out for you, you have to work for it. By working at it, you improve your chances to have happiness. There are parts of happiness that we can't control, but there are also parts that we can control. The parts we can control, such as relationships, accomplishments, etc., are things that we can work on in order to be happy.
      As for the habituation of virtue, I don't think doing something over and over, such as service hours, would necessarily make you happy. Sure, it would help out other people, but would it truly improve your own happiness? I think with happiness you have to be a little selfish and do things that you love, even if they don't necessarily make everyone else around you happy.

      Delete
    2. But does pursuing happiness make you more unhappy? It's like a golf-swing or overthinking a problem on a test. More times than not, if you overthink, you'll trick yourself out of the right answer and get the problem wrong. Like in golf, if you think too much, you will whiff or mess up completely. Happiness is the same way, if you are constantly thinking about it, you most likely won't find it. I do agree with you though that we have to act and pursue happiness to ever hope to find it. Where the line is drawn between being obsessed with finding happiness and pursuing it, I have no idea.

      And your question about helping others: I personally believe that by making other people smile or laugh, I get a sense of fulfillment and joy out of that. Part of my Catholic religion emphasizes helping others in order to be happy myself, but also, I don't know where the line should be drawn between pursuing what you love and doing everything completely for others.

      Delete
    3. You guys all put down some awesome stuff. This one aspect of the Christian philosophy on happiness that puzzles me. We keep talking about handing over the keys to God, but in the Christian faith we are called to take up action and help others so technically we are still in control. Do you believe that we can go to heaven simply based on faith alone or based upon faith and good works. As a strong Catholic, I believe that we are called not only to believe in our faith but to act it out through virtue. What do you guys think?

      Delete
  11. On page 84, McMahon states "we must fear him and keep his commandments." The "he" is referring to God. Based on this quote, my question is: did the early Christians fear God? Were they frightened into believing? The way that the sentence is phrased, it sounds like McMahon is making the point that the early followers of Christ were scared of God. Also, how does the fear of God make them believe in Him? If people followed whomever they were scared of, then why did they not stay true to the emperor? I'm sure that the emperor instilled fear in his subjects. I just want to know why the people were so frightened by God, and why they would follow Him.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's a good question. When McMahon says this, he is talking about the Jewish tradition. Christ's message was not to fear God, but to love him and his creation. Although later people would use Hell and sin to frighten people into doing the right thing, the original message was about love, not fear. But to actually answer the question of "why would anyone want to follow someone they are afraid of?", in Biblical context "fear of the Lord" better translates into being struck down with awe at the power of God, rather than being terrorized into submission.

      Delete
    2. I agree with Matt, instead of actually being afraid, you have a respect of Gods power and there for you "Fear the Lord". You can fear Hell and the devil, but you have respect for God and his power.

      Delete
  12. 77-->"Maikros being the word that hellenized jews used to replace asher ,which was the original word for Happiness, for the Greek Hebrew Bible."
    With this, the Hebrew Beatitudes meaning goes to happy/blessed. But then as we move onto Christianity the Greek influence on both Judaism and schools of thought translates into the New testament beatitudes.

    ReplyDelete
  13. "Happy are those who are persecuted of righteousness's sake, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven." (82). Today in class we talked a lot about how ancient Christians would look forward to their suffering, or persecution, while they are on earth. I thought that it was very interesting to think about the mindset of these ancient Christians. Since they realized that they would suffer in life no matter what, they decided that they might as well be persecuted for something that promises them a reward afterwards. I found it interesting that they had a logical reason to put faith in Christianity. Also I was intrigued by the idea that the people back then thought they had nothing to lose. If they are going to suffer and die anyways they thought it would not hurt to be persecuted for something that promises them something worthwhile after they die.

    ReplyDelete
  14. McMahon discusses how early Christians would've seen heaven as, in the words of Saturus, a "great open space....a garden with rose bushes and all a matter of flowers and trees as tall as cypresses, their leaves constantly falling..." (92). However, as Christianity has evolved from its early stages and developed into Roman Catholicism, the given concept of heaven has certainly changed. Gone are the ideas of paradise and pleasure; from my understanding from years of Catholic education, a Catholic heaven is much less about the individual and more about... worship. That is not to say that worship cannot lead to happiness-- but that happiness could certainly be seen as a different strain than a pleasure-based one. Heaven, for Catholics, is an eternity living in harmony with God and the Communion of Saints, praising and worshipping a creator. Does this modern, evolved heaven detract from the promise of happiness made by the Christian tradition and, does it take away from our hope for heaven in our present? In a way, I think it might. I'm not sure that perpetual worship is something I'm particularly interested in as an afterlife (and feel free to object on your personal grounds), even if eternal praising is a form of "happiness." But if happiness is subjective and someone's idea of happiness isn't necessarily worship, does that mean that a devoted Christian has altered their perceptions of happiness to focus on worship and harmony with God? Does an alteration of our perception of happiness taint it?
    I'm not sure, these are just questions I needed to get out. Sorry that I couldn't answer all of them, I just don't know. (I'm not quite Jesus-y enough to answer them all.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nice! Awesome questions.
      So, I'm not quite Jesus-y either, but in my opinion, maybe a Christian hasn't altered his or her perception to comply with worship or praising, but that it truly is their perspective of happiness--or at least what happiness is supposed to be. Not to forget that we are all products of our upbringing, and oftentimes that is so instilled in us that it becomes the crux of who we are. People are made to worship, whether that is God, a god, chocolate, books, popularity, or other people. I think that worship and the acknowledgement or fulfillment of that worship brings us happiness in its own right.

      Delete
  15. "For all save the crippled and lame, however, there is probably nothing inherently happy about putting one foot in front of the other" - page 78
    McMahon is pointing out that Christianity is not appealing to all people, and originally it's principles did not particularly seem to advocate what many saw a happiness. Putting one foot in front of the other, or, in other words, taking things slowly one step at a time can prove difficult for many, for people tend to want to look ahead. However, methodical advancement is proven to be at times very productive. McMahon is pointing out that it is not an easy thing to do for the average joe.

    ReplyDelete
  16. As Perpetua is lead to her death and her father is begging her to deny her faith and safe her own life, he asks her to "Give up [her] pride!" (McMahon 89). In the eyes of the Christian community, martyrdom was an ultimate sign of submission to God's will. It was God's desire that his followers were humble enough to even lay their own lives at the feet of their God. But for non-Christians, as we assume Perpetua's father was, martyrdom could easily be a very selfish act. It was an easy way out, almost, a blamed suicide where one could escape society, tragedy, and oppression-- and leave the messy work to the ones you left behind. Perpetual didn't have to face and oppressive government or societal structure, didn't have to raise a child in an unjust and difficult world, and was no longer subject to the whims of disease, disaster, and pain that plagued the time period. By submitting to her execution, she was, as some might see it, escaping (in a very extremist way) for her own benefit-- so maybe even selfless acts, seen differently, could be selfish.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you bring up a really interesting point here. Perpetua's act was seen as the right thing to do in her day, but it could just as easily be seen as the opposite, and would most likely be seen that way today. However, I don't think Perpetua sacrificed herself in order to escape the horrors of her world. She was asked to renounce her faith and strongly refused to do just so. Perpetua put her religion above her family, and even above herself. I don't think Perpetua wanted to die. She simply refused to give up her religion, and embraced the consequences that came along with that decision. She was happy to die if it was for her God, but I think she would have been just as happy to live for Him too.

      Delete
  17. "Not surprisingly, the early tribes of Israel held aloft what the world only begrudgingly offered up." -page 79
    This quote provides insight into how the ancient Hebrews thought. In the ancient world, no one really attempted happiness, but simply accepted and held on high what little happiness was put in front of them in their mostly unhappy lives. One did not "seek" happiness in the ancient world in the sense that they could actually obtain it, but one simply had to accept their current lot and lift up the small happiness they would at some point be most likely given by the world simply by luck, chance, or uncontrollable natural forces.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Is it correct in assuming Christianity stems almost directly from Socrates? The sort of passivity or "turn the other cheek" attitude Socrates seemed to advocate seems to directly correlate with Christian teachings. Is Socrates the main influence on Christian teachings? Or are their other significant influences?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. While the idea of turning the other cheek is very similar to Socrates, the other ideas of Christianity are not similar to Socrates. Socrates beleived that we could achieve happiness ourselves IN this life. this is the exact opposite of Christianity, in which one achieves it through GOD and in the next life, so no it is not the main influence.

      Delete
    2. I like what you said about turning the other cheek, but I agree with Conor in saying that there are other, greater influences to Christianity. Also, Socrates places an emphasis on our life as spiritual and mental beings while Christianity puts an emphasis on the physical world as symbols. As Christians we are called to act upon our thought as well, while in Socratic viewpoints we are only called to contemplate. In my opinion, Christianity stems greatly from Aristotle and his views towards living virtuously in our lifetime on Earth.

      Delete
  19. Do Socrates teachings directly correlate with Christianity? Does the "turn the other cheek" attitude Socrates seemed to advocate influence Christianity significantly? Were there other significant influences? I know Epicurus and Zeno both influenced Christianity somewhat, but were their contributions significant, even apparent?

    ReplyDelete
  20. Socrates talked about a higher knowledge, or achieving a higher state of contemplative thinking. Also happiness after death. Was this a heavenly concept? Or is heaven only really introduced with Christianity? Was is a concept before, as in with Socrates and Plato? Or was "heaven" really only officially presented with Jesus?

    ReplyDelete
  21. the Christians and Homeric Greeks both think suffering is necessary to achieve happiness however, the Christians fully embrace and enjoy their happiness. they do so because one of their primary beliefs is that suffering leads to heaven.an example is Perpetua and her friends who when faced with terrible pain, " rejoiced at this that they had obtained a share in the Lords suffering"(76)
    My question is this, if one where a christian living a life of no pain, would they have to create and find their own pain to find a place with Jesus?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Interesting question, I think it would be a very rare case to see anyone, especially early Christians, to be living without pain. Most early converts saw Christ's message and viewed it as a reprieve from their miserable day-to-day lives. Theoretically if there was someone who was living with no pain, they are either living life in a wrong manor because they must have vast amounts of wealth to prevent their pain which should be going to the poor.

      Delete
    2. I agree with Matt. A reoccurring message in the Bible and in Christian practices is that pain and suffering will always be around. I don't think that a person's pain and suffering can just be made, though. I think that pain and suffering are a set of trial set by God to test us. He wants to know if we are capable of still being faithful, even throughout hardships. If one were to create their own pain to find a place with Jesus, it wouldn't be "true" suffering, because the suffering that you are setting upon yourself hasn't been dictated by God, which comes back to my point of our pain and suffering being at the hands of God.

      Delete
    3. You make an interesting point, but I think Matt is right as well. The early Christians believed that suffering on earth is an inevitable aspect of life. The thought of heaven was hope that there was an escape from the suffering that they experienced on earth. For early Christians, the thought of a better afterlife and happiness after death was a relieving idea. All of their suffering would be rewarded in heaven. This hope of heaven probably made all of their suffering on earth seem worth it.

      Delete
  22. Do you think that Aristotle's teachings can be specifically linked to Catholicism?

    In the Catholic Faith, we are called to act upon our belief through faith and good works. In Aristotle's teachings, one must use virtue to help others with the right intention. Therefore, one can see how there is a link between to the two ideas. Also, Catholicism places an emphasis on the physical world as symbols of God, and Aristotle also focuses on the physical world.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, I totally agree. I was just thinking that today in class. Aristotle teaches about how we have to practice virtue, and although we may not like it at first, it will become habitual for us, and then we will end up happy. That, to me, seems really similar to the Christian idea that Mr. Ditzel was talking about today. If ones follows the beatitudes and God's will, it will become habitual and one can find happiness through it.

      Delete
  23. Ecclesiastes 3:13 And also that every man should eat and drink, and enjoy the good of all his labor, it is the gift of God.

    In my opinion, this Bible verse shows how some aspects of Christianity were adopted from the Greek view of living life to the fullest. Although Jesus' teachings contradict with this when he tells others to give away their possessions, many verses can be found that tell us to rejoice in the gifts God has given us in our life instead of taking them for granted. Although it might not be saying to party like the Greeks, it does point out that we should appreciate and soak in the pleasures God has given us.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fantastic!

      People often neglect this point when following their religious beliefs. Many a time we get caught In the idea that the religion must restrict our habits to that of a nun for us to be following it correctly. It is vital to still cherish what we are given for anything we receive is a gift from God wether it is tribulation or triumph.

      Delete
    2. thanks Jack! I really liked what you said about restricting ourselves. We definitely can learn to live life to the fullest.

      Delete
  24. Christianity adds a plot twist to the path to happiness: suffering. By going through this pain, people are able to appreciate the good in life, the littler things, so they ultimately learn to be happy with what they have.I wouldn't say Christians reinvented the acceptance of suffering, they just promoted it. They taught there should be no fear, because ultimately, it'll lead to what people want. According to the Christian concept of suffering, Jesus is a symbol of the happiness to come. He definitely didn't have an easy life, and ended up being persecuted in the end. But, each time one of his disciples tried to stop him, he told them to stop mourning, because he knew he was only going to bring true happiness. While I think Augustine and Aquinas shared many of the same beliefs, I think they shared "less" of the same, because they tried out many theories, and even then, I feel the real, deeper answer didn't come until later philosophers.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you in some aspects, but I don't think that they were suffering so that they could appreciate what they have. Augustine said that the only real glimpse of happiness that people could experience on earth was the hope that they would go to heaven and find true happiness in the afterlife.

      Instead of suffering to appreciate the good things in life, they suffered because they knew that it would eventually bring their eternal life after death. Their lives were modeled after Christ, who suffered on earth to be resurrected into heaven, which was their idea of true happiness.

      Delete
  25. Early Christians did not view happiness and suffering the same way that the Homeric Greeks did. Christians and Greeks share a common idea that suffering is inevitable, but their ideas stem from different beliefs. Though both chose to suffer on earth, both had extremely different reasons for doing so.

    Early Christians were making a choice to suffer on earth. The ancient Greeks, on the other hand, did not make a choice in their suffering, because they believed that their suffering was a part of their fate.

    "Happy are those who are persecuted of righteousness's sake, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven." Page 82. This quote well describes the beliefs of the early Christians.

    The ancient Greeks relied entirely on destiny, letting suffering come to them without trying to alter their lives for the better. Christians, however, believed that suffering and misery was a reminder of how much better things would be for them in the next life. They did not believe in chance or luck, like the Greeks did. Christians believed that in their current suffering, they would be freed from their suffering. The believed that their earthly suffering would lead to the loss of their suffering in the next life, because God made them a promise that they would find life in death. Through their suffering, happiness would be created after they were saved by death. Christians believed that, like Christ, they had to suffer, because this would make them become more like Christ.

    Christian beliefs were also different from the beliefs of the ancient Greeks because Christianity offered hope for people who never had this hope before (women especially). The early Greeks did not have hope. They relied on good fortune and luck. This just emphasizes the lack of a choice that the Greeks had in their inevitable suffering.

    Are there any other links to the ancient Greek world that I haven't understood? It seems that some of the ideas between the two cultures are associated, but the beliefs come from different backgrounds and have different reasoning.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right on the money.

      I do think the ideas had to be mixing about just given their geographic locations. Christianity was certainly influenced by Greek culture so they may not be as exclusive as you lay out, but your analysis is spot on.

      Delete
    2. Ally I really like the way you put this. I think a part of the reason why Christianity was successful is that it has been influenced by other cultures and also that it has been changed and altered adds to it's success.

      Delete
  26. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  27. On page 94, it says that "Paul understood that the fleeting pleasures of the world-mortal life itself- was but a small sacrifice to make in return for life eternal." This sounds very similar to the ancient view that suffering occurs during your lifetime, but true happiness comes in death. However, I think the view of Christianity is more clear that happiness comes not in death, but in achieving eternal life. But are these "fleeting pleasures" considered happiness, or are they just that- fleeting pleasures? Is Jesus the epitome of Christian happiness? He suffered, died, and was buried, but then he rose to eternal life. I think that Jesus embodies the view that suffering must occur in order to achieve eternal life, leading to eternal happiness. The crucifixion is considered a "victory over suffering, death, and despair." We should follow this example to achieve our own happiness in eternal life. I personally agree that suffering is important on the road to happiness because you will not be able to truly appreciate happiness unless you have suffered.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What is interesting is that suffering opens the door to make bad decisions in addition to accepting Christ. Those suffering from all manner of problems (mental/physical/social/financial) tend to "give in to desire" and drink/smoke/etc. or in Mr. Ditzel's description, try to change things. It is an interesting path indeed.

      Delete
    2. These problems may also encourage either the further distancing or eventual strengthening of ones relationship with God. Once we have given into desire the regret that may eventually follow may be even stronger than the opener of the "door" in its pushing one towards God through continued struggle. Could it possible to say that suffering more from these extended periods of suffering (from regret or effects of the bad decision) could be more beneficial than merely suffering and moving on?

      Delete
    3. Kate, I really like where you're going with this. It was a really interesting way of putting it that I didn't think about. I have to agree with you that suffering on the road to happiness because without suffering you can't appreciate happiness

      Delete
  28. Christianity introduced a revolutionary concept. Christians not only agreed that there was suffering in the world and everybody goes through it, but they also believed that happiness came directly from suffering. This idea is unlike any before. It is mind blowing. Christianity opened the door for more people to attain happiness than ever before as well, as we see through the story of Perpetua in our book. Perpetua happily accepted death, even as she knew she would leave behind her baby. She was so joyous to die, because she full-hearted believed that through death, she would find the happiness that Christianity preached. Christians didn't simply reinvent the Homeric version of suffering. The ancient Greeks also believed happiness could only be determined and achieved at death, but unlike the Greeks, Christianity promised a savior or hope after all of people's suffering. Christianity said, "Hey, I know all of you suffer, but your reward in Heaven will make all of the suffering so worth it."

    I guess my question after the class-discussion is: Is the Homeric Greek idea of fate not the same thing as the Christian's mentality of God's will and path for us in life?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would argue it is different. Under the Homeric Greeks you did everything you could but then left it up for chance in the end to dictate your happiness after death. As a Christian, you choose to turn yourself over to God (chance/fate/etc.) and then you ARE happy in heaven (no chance, it is the result).

      Delete
  29. One side of Christian philosophy on happiness emphasizes the idea of happiness through suffering. We are meant to rejoice in suffering because (1) it unites us with Christ in his suffering and (2) it will one day end (heaven). We are rejoicing for something that is yet to come, but it is so great that we rejoice in it even now before it happens. But we don't know what it is. Heaven, to us, is supposedly unimaginable bliss. So we're meant to not only accept our pain, but also rejoice in it because of the promise of eternal life, and although we know heaven will mean the end of all pain, we don't know much more about it. To me, it seems difficult to be happy about all of the pain in this life just because of the promise of the next life, especially when I don't even know what the next life is gonna be like. How do we keep our faith that the next life is worth it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think the text says that there was a growing conception of heaven fed by jewish, pagan and early Christian images.

      I guess this is what "faith" is all about?

      Delete
  30. How does Christianity change things?

    Christianity completely throws out the idea that one needs to live in moderation and that one can't live a life of suffering in order to become happy. It shows a new interpretation of the belief that one must be dead to be happy, however the attainment of this happiness was by different means. It used to be (during the ancient greek age before Aristotle) that one must live a good life and die at the peak of their athleticism pulling their mother in a cart, or dying a glorious and heroic death in battle. Under the Christian view, one must be glad one is suffering, because it means that things can only get better. On page 76, it McMahon says that in a first-hand account, perpetua and the other persecuted Christians "rejoiced ... that they had obtained a share in the Lord's suffering." Mcmahon also says it was unlikely anyone had ever seen someone rejoicing in their pain. This is a very optimistic outlook on happiness, especially for those who already suffer, because it means that they too can share in the happiness.

    ReplyDelete
  31. In class we talked a lot about the mindset of early Christians and what suffering meant to them. To the early Christians, suffering was a part of their faith and it was a part of their experience as being devout followers of God. I was very impressed by this optimistic outlook towards suffering and living through the hardships in one's life. I know I have struggled in my faith in believing that things that I'm going through are apart of life, and I've doubted my faith at times too. And when I think about it, my "hardships" in my life have been no where near as difficult as to what these ancient Christians lived with. It's hard not to pull the whole "why me?" card and become angry with God. So you have to kind of ask yourself could you have faith that all your suffering was apart of your faith? Do you think you could keep this optimistic thought process while being in pain or a time of tribulation?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sometimes i feel when we question God, his answers (or the lack there of) seem to be found in the future. This period of questioning may either affirm ones love of God or crush it. Quite a tight rope to walk.

      Delete
    2. I think that this is probably the hardest part of this Christian mindset on suffering. It would be really hard to keep a positive mindset during suffering, and like Jack said, it only makes it harder when you don't get any concrete answers from God. At some points, it's going to seem much easier to give into things that can make you temporarily happy during this life, instead of going through suffering with just the hope of happiness in an eternal life- if you have enough faith that that exists. I think it would be difficult to be optimistic through this suffering without any concrete answers from God.

      Delete
    3. I think there are some people who definately believe that everything happens for a reason, so their suffering is part of God's will. While I believe some people use this as an excuse when things don't turn out as expected, it's fully plausible for them to maintain the faith and know that things will get better. Just knowing there's a possibility of things getting better does allow them to keep up the optimism, I just think there's only a few choice people who can do it.

      Delete
  32. Mr. Ditzel talked about the beatitudes in class today, but a common message that I'm receiving from all of them is that one needs to take God for granted in order to follow the beatitudes. Naturally, it would be easy for Jews to convert and follow the beatitudes, because the Jewish and Christian god is the same. However, as thetimes progressed and as the Christian church became almost completely converted Greeks, what would have made the Greeks accept the Christian God in order to follow the beatitudes?

    I'm pretty sure this was because they were looking for something to be greater than themselves, and weren;t looking for a creationist religion like ancient Greek, but were rather looking for a religion with a righteous God who encouraged goodness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can see where you are coming from, but I don't think that the beatitudes were designed only for people who took God for granted. The first three beatitudes are all about realizing the error in your ways and knocking you down. To realize your errors, you don't have to worsen them by adding to them. I agree with the rest of what you are saying.

      Delete
    2. While it may seem like the Beatitudes were messages that were made for those taking God for granted, it would make more sense to be a set of rules for those that want to be more in touch with God. Think about it: For someone who would be taking God for granted, he wouldn't really enjoy the first three beatitudes, since they would consist of being knocked down up until you know how powerless you really are. The next four Beatitudes also wouldn't be taken to seriously, considering the fact that if he/she takes God for granted, they wouldn't really believe that he would fill him/her up with love, grace, etc. While I do agree with your point to a certain degree, the Beatitudes are more directed towards those people that want to be more in touch with God than those who take him for granted.

      Delete
  33. "Happy are those...who walk in the law of the Lord." (Psalms 119:1, referenced in our text on pg. 78)
    In Christianity-- and frequently in our text-- we are given the idea of our lives as a path that follows the life of Jesus and God's will. We are supposed to walk the path in Jesus' footsteps and live as he did. I find that this path, God's path, is the right one. The Beatitudes are a fantastic way to live and to attain happiness. So much of the philosophy on happiness which we have studied has been focused mainly on the individual. Although philosophies like Aristotle's include living a life of virtue, but it still doesn't have the outward focus that Christianity does.
    Christian philosophy emphasizes humility. It's about doing good simply because it is good, and recognizing that even when we do something good, it's God who has the power, and it is He to whom we should accredit our actions. In doing this, we are promised happiness (as all the beatitudes start with "blessed are" or "happy are"). Christian philosophy, instead of suggesting that we begin searching for happiness or progressing through a method to attain it, suggests that we begin by doing good and promises us that happiness will come from it. Whereas Aristotle said that to be happy we should live a life of virtue, Christian philosophy says that we should live a life of virtue just because it's the right thing to do and that happiness will result from it. It's less about getting happiness for ourselves and more about living on the right path, doing the right thing, and being compassionate and kind towards others, and then gaining happiness from it.
    It's not all about us. It's about others, and about God.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. While it is based on humility, you can see that religion at this point was more central to lives of those for pretty much all of history up until about the renaissances. where at this point people shifted to secularism and individualism. I believe that with this we can achieve the same humility while still celebrating ourselves. And yes.

      Delete
    2. I agree. We can definitely achieve humility even while celebrating ourselves. I just mean to say that this is a very different kind of happiness that is primarily based on other and on God rather than the individual. And in addition to having that humility of giving credit to others and to God, you can celebrate yourself. There's this quote that I really like that I think explains what I'm trying to say: "Humility isn't thinking less of yourself. It's thinking of yourself less."

      Delete
  34. Mr. Ditzel explained the Beatitude that says "Blessed are those who mourn, for they shall be comforted" by saying that mourning is okay, because it makes us realize that things could've turned out differently. Essentially, it's good to think of all the "what if" situations, and express sadness over what didn't happen, or what we don't have. Doesn't this defeat the whole teaching of the ancient philosophers we just learned about who taught that appreciating what we have, what we can control, is what brings us joy? So those who are happy with what they have now aren't being "Christian enough" because they're not wanting for more? In my previous point, I said that I believed the Christians were sharing more or less of the same beliefs as the Greeks. As I look into other perspectives, I think Christianity begins to contradict them. After today's presentation, I took away that those who are happy with how things are right now are committing a sin against Christianity because they're wanting for nothing, so they don't desire God.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really liked Mr. Ditzel's point about the difference between mourning and sadness. He stated that mourning is the realization that things could have gone differently and that you could have had a part in making them different. I feel like the whole point of mourning isn't to dwell on the past but to help with the future. When mourning, you rerun what happened over and over again in your head. This is a learning experience for the future. So, when you encounter a similar situation, you'll know what to do. On the subject of the "what if" situations, I don't think it is the same thing. You can't mourn over something that didn't happen. I believe that you can be sad about it but not mourn. For instance, if I was thinking of adopting a cat, I could think of all the possible "what ifs" that could happen. "What if I get a cat and I forget to feed it, and it dies?" or "What if the cat runaway from home and gets killed by a coyote?" I could think of all those situations and get sad about it, but I can't mourn them. I can't think "what could I have done differently?" because I didn't actually do anything.

      Delete
  35. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Question:
    With all of this breaking down the human looks at etc in Christianity and being filled with God. I Feel that it is a cop out. Sort of like pre-Socratic and such views on life. As in, People have no control and put all their belief into a supposedly benevolent God. So translating that into christian views, you see that people are giving credit to God, rather than themselves which is essentially disillusioning themselves. is that a valid way to look at it?That is my question.

    ReplyDelete
  37. so there's been a lot of talk suffering. with this i feel, it affirms the fact that for a lot of people had the conception that in order to be happy one must suffer first hand. I said something similar to this in the Buddhism comment because Siddhartha (Buddha) also suffered. So yeah. this seems to be a common trend within faiths.

    ReplyDelete