Sunday, December 15, 2013

Week #2 - Confucius, Mencius, Buddhism and more

I had created this last week...not sure why it didn't stick.  I am sorry for the inconvenience!

67 comments:

  1. "Mencius argues that the mind derives pleasure form "principle and righteousness" in the same way we derive pleasure from satisfying our physical inclinations."
    What Mencius is saying is that there are two places that people can get pleasure from. One place you can get pleasure from is principle and righteousness. This idea comes back to what we talked about in class today. The root of happiness, if it is seeded pleasure (I am not saying it is or isn't, but lets just say that it is for the sake of this discussion), would be to find what gives us pleasure. Mencius says that doing good deeds to fulfill our need for righteousness is one way to gain pleasure. When we discussed this today the topic of intent was thrown around a lot. The issue of right or wrong intent making an action righteous or not came up. I believe that no matter what the intent is the end result is the same. If you do something good it is still a righteous deed, even if you only did it to look good instead of doing it out of kindness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think that you put up a very good argument, but I disagree on the value of intent. In my opinion, intent is necessary to make a change on yourself. If you don't have intent, I agree it is still somewhat virtuous because it makes an impact on others, but if you keep doing actions without intent your whole life, you will never change yourself.

      Delete
  2. Today we attempted to understand how one must eliminate the desire to be happy while making others happy to gain happiness in the Confucian mindset. My question is: Can one still pick up this way of thought because they want to be happy, or will they never achieve happiness in Confucius' view as some thought today in class?

    In my opinion, if one joins Confucianism with the desire to gain happiness, they can still achieve happiness because the habituation of their actions and virtues allows for them to start helping others for the right reasons. Although, like Confucius points out, it is not until then that they will actually gain happiness. Also, I believe that all acts that help others are not considered virtuous if they are not done for the right reasons. They are indeed helpful though in leading one to the point where their heart is in what they are doing. A good example of this is religion. As a child, you go to mass simply because you have to, but later on you gain a desire to pray and talk to God. Therefore, I believe that one can not be inherently virtuous.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Possibly going through the motions may give us justification for them. Maybe we get so attached to doing these things (as we consider them normal and routine) that when we consider them, we hold them in a higher value. Later on, after the routinization of these acts we realize that they were meant to help others and ourselves and we are able to justify them.

      Delete
    2. Jack are you saying the monotony of routines numbs us to the fact that they are somewhat insignificant? Well, not insignificant, just not an important factor in achieving happiness because the routine itself becomes...well it becomes routine. Nothing special.

      Delete
  3. As we all know from the assigned reading, the Buddha experimented with aestheticism after he had lived in a style of overindulgence his entire life. He found no peace, happiness, or meaning in either of these practices, so he came up with his own. We know it as the middle path. When put into context with what the ancient Greeks commonly believed, being living in excess and overindulgence, are these two paths to happiness even reaching towards the same goal? They are both based off of a lack of suffering, but it seems to me like the Buddha's belief is finding a way to let go of pain and suffering to achieve happiness in the afterlife, while the Greeks were simply partying on earth to escape from the suffering. So my question is, are their goals completely different, or are they both trying to achieve the same thing, just in different ways?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. To clarify, my stance is that they are both trying to achieve happiness, but their idea of happiness is not the same.

      Delete
    2. I think that makes a lot of sense, that they're both trying to achieve happiness but their definitions of what this happiness is are completely different. The ways of obtaining it though, are somewhat similar, because like you said, they both are trying to escape pain and suffering. I think the difference comes into play here. The Greeks defined happiness as the way that they escaped pain and suffering, but Buddhists defined happiness as what comes after you escape pain and suffering. So the Greeks defined happiness on how they temporarily escaped pain and suffering, but the Buddhists defined it based on the actual absence of pain and suffering, in my opinion.

      Delete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. In the Buddhism reading it states, "All that we are is the result of what we have thought." I find this idea to be true. If a person thinks of themselves as happy, then they are. No one else can tell them if they are happy or not. As Mr. Heintz said today in class, a person may act happy but be depressed on the inside. In that case, though others say that person is happy, they are not. I also think an important word in the quote is "have." By making it "what we have thought," that includes all out past experiences. You could replace the word "thought with something like "experienced" and the meaning would be the same. Going off of what I said in class, I think a person's experiences are what define them. Everyone is influenced by what happens around them in one way or another. The way people think is influenced by past experiences. Buddha is saying is that we have the power to decide how we react to things and whether we are going to be happy or not. The way we react to things depends on how we think, and how we think is influenced by the world around us.

    ReplyDelete
  6. "The journey to attain a deeper form of happiness requires an unflinching look into the face of a reality where all life is seen as dukkha or mental dysfunction."

    The quote above does a great job of summarizing the views of Buddhism. In my opinion, all of life is seen as "dukkha" because without mental control or the Eight Fold Path, it would be almost impossible to eliminate desire, suffering, and mental distractions. I think that the term used for these problems helps account for the mental improvement and contentment that some Greek Scholars did not include in their philosophy. Overall, Buddhism is very appealing to me because I always seek to eliminate unnecessary desires in my life whenever I can.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This quote kind of ties into what Benji was talking about today in class. He asked if you could achieve happiness without experiencing suffering, and this quote is basically telling us that we can't. It is saying how we have to look at the suffering in life and accept it so that we can obtain happiness. When we realize all of the suffering around us and even some of the suffering that we have endured, it makes life seem so much happier. Looking at all the negatives that I, personally, have overcome makes me feel pretty great. And, looking at the suffering around me makes me thankful and appreciative for what I have. So, I agree with this statement. I think it is important to look at all the suffering in life, so that we can move past it to a deeper happiness.

      Delete
    2. I agree with you will. i think there is a certain appeal of Buddhism to everyone through the controlling of emotions. i also find that dukkha is an extension of epicurian acolyte that not only helps us control our desires but our emotions too.

      Delete
  7. So for Mencius, we have these "lesser selves" and these "deeper selves" and "moral sprouts" that will grow with the tender loving care of virtuous actions. But not just any virtuous actions, only the ones that are done for the right reasons and in the right way rather than just doing good for the sake of the sprout growth. I'm going to connect some not-quite-lining up dots here and ask a question Aristotle was asked. What about that poor soul who "suffers the worst evils and misfortunes" even though they are virtuous? Would Mencius say that it's an impossible situation as anyone who is virtuous would not suffer the worst evils? Or is "evil" somehting that can't and won't just befall someone in the optimistic Mencian philosophy? For where there is happiness, there's got to be some sort of opposing force, right? Or is Mencius' opposing force merely the lesser self that can dominate someone who is not acting virtuously in the correct, recommended way?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would assume that for Mencius, the virtuous people who suffer just haven't gained enough of the knowledge they need to to form a foundation of morality before making decisions that affect them and other people. And even if they act virtuously, it might not be true virtue- because a truly virtuous person, for Mencius, would probably be able to accept what comes to them and feel more of an indifference or acceptance than suffering.

      Delete
  8. Confucius says, "We have the power to transform ourselves"
    Gosh, what a great way to go about life. Even when it seems we're down and out, high and dry, "as destituted as a kid could be," we will always have happiness if we want to have happiness because it is within the realms of human capability to grab it. Even if it does seem somewhat unrealistically optimistic, I like Confucian ideology. He recognizes that a normal, common person is going to try to achieve happiness through doing the right thing and then lighting up a neon sign pointing out how virtous and wonderful and praiseworthy they are (connecting to the Homeric idea of honor, anyone?). Instead, we should be in it for the betterment of ourselves, to learn about our own humanity. It's the equivalent of the Christian "don't let the left hand see what the right hand is doing" sort of thing. Do good deeds for the sake of doing good deeds because the self-knowledge that comes along with them is beneficial to your humanity in the long run. Be noble in your humanity, be honorable because you're a secret do-gooder. If we have the power to transform ourselves, then the transformation must start from a personal, individual desire to become more secure in our humanity, which lends itself to the desire to practice it regularly. Starting with self and sharing this with others, Confucius argues, is what ultimately will make us happier people. I can live with that.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Is total peace of mind happiness? In the Buddhism reading, it talks about the different stages of happiness and how even bliss must disappear to reveal total peace of mind. In the first step to happiness, a person must get rid of all mental hinderances. That I get. It makes sense to et rid of all the negative stuff in your head. Then, a person has to eliminate all the distractions or "activities." Again, that makes sense. If you wan tho focus on happiness, your mind can't be jumping around. Then, the bliss you got from clearing your mind disappears. So, in order to be happy bliss (another word for happiness) has to go away? And finally, all your feelings of bliss have to go away to reveal "total peace of mind." So, my question is: Is the absence of everything and complete peace of mind happiness or just contentment?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That’s a great question. I’m not sure this question can be answered by a sweeping general statement for an answer. It all depends on the definition of happiness and contentment for that person. I think most people would be content having complete mental peace, but some people may not be happy. The people who feel it necessary to solve problems and to keep their mind working very fast may not want an empty head.

      Delete
  10. Taylor Bradley

    The Eightfold path in Buddhism is like the habituation of virtuous deeds (or otherwise called the Zen of Ethics in Mr. Fecas's Choices class). This path conditions people into obtaining a certain mind frame to obtain happiness (or the lack of suffering), which requires a lot of hard work. Likewise, the habituation of doing good deeds, regardless of whether the intentions were pure or not, will eventually reveal all of the good that comes out of these actions. Once one realize the good ends that the means produce, the intent gradually shifts from indifference to compassion, from apathy to doing things for the "right" reasons. An example used in class today was community service. At first, people do not want to take the extra time out of their already busy lives to help others. However, as they are required to serve their community, they suddenly begin to realize how small their own problems are in comparison to those they are helping in that moment. A simple change in perspective can alter our intentions and motivate us to do things because we feel they are right.

    Meditation can serve as a method to change our perspective and to motivate us to have the right intentions as well. Meditation, from the Buddhism view, is a look within each of ourselves, which allows us to focus on the mental aspects of our lives. This method is extremely useful today, because so many of our sickness are illnesses of the mind such as depression. Through meditation our thinking becomes more clear, which advances us a step along the Eightfold path, eventually seeking full control over our mind. The end of suffering is the ultimate sort of happiness, according to Buddhists, so if most of our anguish and stress is caused by our own mind, then we should strive to help ourselves in a sense. This goes against Mencius's thought of helping others and in turn, you will find happiness, but more so focuses on helping ourselves as the most important way to end suffering.

    Also, the question I had while reading the Buddhist passage was: how do you create a balance between meditation, focusing inward on your own mind (Buddhist's mind set), and helping others, which as a result makes you happy (Mencius's way of thinking)?

    ReplyDelete
  11. It seems that when we talk about happiness, we tend to focus a lot on thought and mental suffering, but not so much on things outside of us or physical suffering. When we first began talking about happiness in ancient Greece, it was all about what happened to you. It was almost completely outside factors that made up happiness. Now, in Buddhism, it seems like there seems to be an extreme focus on inside factors. Buddhists believe that if you attain inner peace, the things outside of you don't matter.
    I tend to agree with this philosophy, but it still seems like the extreme opposite of the happiness we first learned about. Even though I think that we do ultimately control our happiness and that thought and inside factors are more important, I don't think the outside factors can ever have absolutely no effect on us. For example, what about physical pain? You cannot think away illness or a broken leg; it's still going to hurt. Even if one has completely blocked out all negative thoughts and emotions, he/she is still going to feel that pain, and there has to be some level of unhappiness that results from it. How do we deal with the bad things in life that happen to us that we absolutely cannot control, like physical pain? Do these sort of things have a big influence on our happiness?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you, Gracie, that we can't just pretend that outside factors aren't going to affect us negatively in any way. In both philosophies, we were taught to only let what we can control affect us. But, if we can't control outside factors, how can we control the good or bad they place on us? I think there exist a few people who have the power to not let physical pain, like the broken leg, break their spirit. However, I doubt we'd be able to find someone who is happy to have broken it. So, while we may not be miserable, I believe it's more of an indifference.

      Delete
    2. That makes sense. I guess even if you'll never be happy about pain, you can choose to not let it break your spirits, even though that takes a lot of mental/will power.

      Delete
  12. “In death, the story goes that a follower accidentally poisoned Buddha. As he was dying, he comforted this follower by assuring him that the meal he had just eaten was one of his two most blessed meals; the first meal was the one he had to break his fast under the bodhi tree, and this second meal of rotten mushrooms was the meal that would bring him to Nirvana.”
    This quote does a great job of encompassing the essential quality of the Buddha. Even though a follower of his carelessly and mistakenly killed his master, the Buddha never thinks anything of it. He even goes as far as saying that it was a good thing that he’s dying so he can enter into Nirvana. Only an individual who has a perfect state of mind can forgive someone who has just poisoned them while 99.999% of people’s first emotion would be intense anger and hatred toward the incidental killer.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. This aspect of passivity is so key in Buddhism. It just seems to me to be impossible to be THAT understanding and compassionate towards everything. Even though I think it is a great philosophy, I feel like it's nearly impossible to develop this passivity towards ALL things. All philosophies are hard to fully abide by though, no matter which one we are discussing. If things were easy we wouldn't be having a class about it. I understand that. It's hard to think anyone could fully achieve this though, but I do believe it is possible. The work involved is INSANE though.

      Delete
  13. Does the Eightfold Path have to be followed just as it is presented in this article or can one hop around and focus on multiple parts at one time?
    From what I’m observing, it seems that you need to focus on each set (Wisdom, Ethical Conduct, Ethical Cultivation) in order to move on to the next. For example, first one must be wise in order to know how to conduct yourself properly.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, each path is related to each other. one can not skip one and come back because they will not fully understand how to do the new path.

      Delete
  14. I see Buddhism as a mix between stoicism and the Aristotelian mean. A balance between pleasure and conservatism along with reducing the desires that you have in order to achieve happiness. You can see forms of other philosophers incorporated. My question is suffering all that bad? isn't suffering part of the human experience to grow?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think suffering is mandatory for someone to feel ultimate happiness. There’s a great quote from The Count of Monte Cristo which says “There is no such thing as happiness or unhappiness, only the comparison of the two. Only one who has felt ultimate despair can feel ultimate bliss.” For example, if an underprivileged child and I both receive the same gift for Christmas, the underprivileged child would be much more grateful for the present.

      Delete
    2. Good question, Benji. And Matt, I agree with you that he'd be more grateful, but that doesn't mean you aren't happy. Like we said, there are levels of happiness. So I have a question: Is ultimate bliss worth the suffering one must endure to feel it, or is general happiness with little to no suffering the better answer?

      Delete
    3. Not EVERY type of education is ineffective. For example, mathematics, science, and language. It's kind of hard to teach about all sides of a conflict in math, because math is numbers and doesn't involve opinions which would lead to conflicts. There can be a conflict in the history of math, but that would technically be social studies. I agree that social studies should be taught objectively, but in some cases, even that isn't possible. The winner writes the history books, and sometimes the winner completely wiped out it's opponent, therefore it's kind of hard to look at history from the loser's POV. Still possible, but hard.

      Delete
  15. Confucius believed in an orderly society, where everyone has their place in society. However, your place and role changes since you have more than one role in society. When one feels comfortable in their place among others, one can prosper and grow since they feel accepted. Does this relate to how many people feel that once they have reach a place of contentment they are happy? Because they are satisfied with their role in the world that they live in?

    ReplyDelete
  16. -Cong fu su ( or master/ teacher) (master Cung)Confucius: His views on society was that if everyone stays and sticks to the statisquo and be nice to each other than society will be in order. Stepping away from a government based on fear and punishment.“better angels of their nature”: people can be taught to do the right thing and be taught values to keep lasting order in society. Or in other words: Do this and you’ll be a better person and our society will be better as a whole. You have a personal responsibility to our society

    5 great relationship in society
    1. Ruler and subject
    2. Parents and Child
    3. husband and wife
    4. older brother younger brother (patriarchal) (older sibling to younger sibling)
    5. Teacher and student (friend to friend)
    The people on right have to give RESPECT and HONOR to the ones on right
    Honor and obey them
    But the left also has to be concerned for their well being growth and benefit
    They need to show they care for those underneath them
    If we educate people to be better to each other we will create a long lasting harmony in society within each piece and part serving and playing their important part
    You are one part of a societal whole. You don’t do your part and chaos will be the result
    Silver rule: same as golden rule
    Does this relate to how people feel that when they are content they are happy or have reach happiness? Do we have to feel accepted to reach happiness?



    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think it is very important for one to feel accepted in order to be happy. Bullying is a clear result of when someone is not accepted, and usually those who are bullied are not too happy. Although we may think that acceptance merely relies on other people, the subject of the desired acceptance must also value themselves before others do so. So, yes. Being accepted is usually necessary to feel happy. (Although there are always weird cases.

      Delete
  17. Going on what benji said that Buddhism is a mix between stoicism and the Aristotelian mean. A balance between pleasure and conservatism along with reducing the desires that you have in order to achieve happiness. What would the Buddha and Aristotle say if they met. What would they agree and disagree on? I think they would agree on getting rid of needs. both Buddhist and Aristotle teachings, talk about finding the source of unhappiness and getting rid or forgetting it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Although I agree with what you are saying, in my opinion, the "reward" of following the two philosophies is different. In following the Aristotelian philosophy, one is happy because they have lived an easy life virtuously and have been rewarded with material pleasures. In Buddhism, one is left with an emptiness of pain in suffering. Therefore, Buddhism is defined as an absence of something rather than obtaining something like in Aristotle's view.

      Delete
  18. Towards the end of "Equanimity a deep sense of well being and happiness is attainable through proper knowledge and practice in everyday life." Though this quote seems like a dead end (as it is a conclusion sentence), i think it leaves a great deal up for discussion. Though the idea of proper knowledge is major tenant of the Buddhist search for happiness, is it solely intending said knowledge to be of positive things? Could this knowledge be found when one experiences a great deal of pain or commits a terrible act. Many a time in my life, i have found that those experiences that are negative we learn the most from. Though i would imagine that the idea of practice could work the same way, that may be a stretch.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Today's speaker was fantastic and his ideas of elimination of suffering were well placed. He also did an excellent job of clarifying the idea that happiness is not necessarily selfish once one begins the correct practice and it benefits others. Though this makes sense, what would draw the line between whether an action is out of primal and selfish happiness or whether it is out of true desire to do good? is this idea only applicable for those who perform the action? What draws the line? Could this line be drawn solely by the performer and in that case, could correct happiness only be a personal idea not a judge-able trait?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'd say that there really can't be a general "line" drawn since only the person doing the good act could know their intentions. Doing things for selfish reasons may not bring the same happiness as one would get from just doing the right thing. However, you could still be happy that you did something good for another person, even if your intentions are selfish. You sort of have to be a little selfish to be happy because you are thinking about your self and your own well-being.

      Delete
  20. Question: What I found interesting from the monk’s lecture was that so much of happiness is affiliated with the mind. My question is to what extent one can control their mind in order to suppress desires?
    I know that Buddhism uses meditation in order to control their mind, and therefore be happier. But as humans, how can we actually control what we think about? Even if you consciously are avoiding thinking about something, you still have to think about that thing, if that makes sense… Also, I don’t see how you can suppress your desires through the mind. Sure, you can try to focus less on your desires, but I feel like no matter what we do, they are still there. And if our desires include things like our hopes and dreams, why would those be things that we would want to suppress?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I guess for Buddhists and those focusing on a contemplation-like control of desires, it can't just be about controlling and shutting down our minds. We have a subconscious that, like you said, makes us think about things we can't control (even when we think about not thinking about them). So maybe instead of just suppressing ideas, it's more about prioritizing and emphasizing the "right" kind of thoughts and recognizing that other things are less important. So in that way, hopes and dreams, which are desires but probably "good" desires don't necessarily have to be suppressed.

      Delete
  21. Quote: Mencious was famous for arguing that “deep down, we are endowed with the “sprouts” of humanity and righteousness, and we simply need to steadily cultivate those sprouts to become virtuous people”
    From this quote I get this really cute image of a little plant growing up and being watered like in a nursery rhyme until it is all full grown and virtuous. For some reason, I don’t think the process is this cute. In class the other day, we talked a little about how the way people grown up affects their virtue. I’d say that often, the way that people are brought up doesn’t help the “plant” grow, but often ruins their virtue. Sure, I think everyone is “endowed with the sprouts of humanity and righteousness” deep down, but as people grow, I think their virtue could go in the opposite direction.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I totally agree with the cute image of a little plant! I thought of the same thing. But, you said that you don't think that people'e upbringing have a positive effect on them. I feel like it depends on the person and their upbringing. Not all parents are terrible, awful people. I think that many times they have a positive effect on their children. I can only speak from my own experience, but I owe many of my best qualities to my parents. They are the ones who taught me right from wrong and good manners from a very young age. I am lucky that I had that kind of positive upbringing. You do have a point. Parents have a huge impact on their children, and if they set the wrong example, things could go downhill quickly. As people grow up, they have a choice: try to stay true to their original "sprouts" of virtue or ignore them. It is kind of pessimistic to assume that all people will ruin their virtues. I have faith that not everyone turns out rotten.

      Delete
  22. In class and with the monk's presentation today, we discussed how intentionality affects our own personal happiness- how, according to Buddhism (and, similarly, Confucianism) without proper intention to do good (just for the sake of goodness), then we cannot become happy. What I'm wondering if bad intention takes away from the act itself. We had discussed that virtuous "acts" aren't really virtuous without good intentions, but you can't dismiss that good acts, no matter the intention, still cause good in the end. I guess what I'm asking is, can bad intentions take away from how good actions affect other people, not just ourselves? I think that no matter what the intention, good actions are still going to do good in the world. But perhaps in the perspective of Confucianism or Buddhism, these good actions are detracted from, but I want to know how someone can say that given the "objective" good of good deeds- if that makes sense.

    ReplyDelete
  23. In the Mencius reading, the author discusses how Confucius and Mencius both emphasize a "practical wisdom," which in a way ties in to the Confucius reading's discussion of "humanity [as a] practical sympathy." I think that here is the largest discrepancy between these Eastern thinkers and their Western contemporaries: the difference between a practical wisdom and wisdom more based in abstract thought and contemplation. Socrates, Plato, and eventually even Aristotle argue that happiness is best brought about through contemplation and more passive actions; they leave happiness up to fate and other deciding factors and less on actions themselves. But Confucius and Mencius decide that happiness is acting on the suffering you see in the world, acting in according to your place in society, and acting based on what is right for the sake of doing the right thing. This contrast, between thinking and acting, shows the differences in schools of thought between the Eastern and Western tradition, even in the early stages of philosophy.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I find it interesting that the Buddha, "saw personal happiness as related to the happiness of others..." because Buddhism seems to be very focused on self and this idea of understanding ourselves in order to attain happiness. It's all about meditation and learning to balance one's own life, but at the same time, it has very much to do with others. Like our speaker talked about today, Buddhists are focused on harmlessness towards themselves and towards others. In hurting others, we will inevitably hurt ourselves, and vice versa, so harmlessness is an important thing to practice, no doubt. Going beyond just harmlessness, Buddhists practice compassion towards others. The whole human family in connected because we all feel and because of our fundamental common aspiration for happiness, so not only empathy, but also compassion is another important practice. Buddhists will actually often meditate on compassion, sometimes for a specific group of people who are in need. This type of meditation goes not just to benefit oneself, but to benefit others as well. This compassion takes the inward focus of Buddhism and turns it outwards.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really like where you're going with this Gracie! I agree that in order to obtain happiness we must not only create harmlessness in our own lives but also in others lives. Treating others properly helps makes the world go round. i think that there is a reason why we feel a sense of guilt after hurting others, and that its impossible to be happy while knowing you've hurt someone. For this reason, I think happiness relates more to being joyful, not just being happy.
      Being filled with joy differs from being happy in many ways. when someone is joyful it doesn't just mean their happy all the time. Being joyful is knowing that no matter what happens to you, you have faith (in some cases faith in God) that things will work out because it just wasn't meant to be. You can still be sad but you have this positive attitude, and that positive outlook can be seen by others. When others see this joy, they have hope that they can think like that too. Therefore, happiness is meant to be experienced not only including oneself (inwardly) but with others as well (outwardly).

      Delete
    2. The Buddhist monk told us about how Buddhism focused on harmlessness to achieve personal happiness. He said that we had to focus on being harmless to not only ourselves, but to others. So I agree with you that Buddhism beliefs focus on living virtuously towards others as well as yourself! I also agree with you on your point that compassion towards others can bring about happiness for someone. I know that I find happiness in helping another person. It's a cycle: If you help someone, they might want to help someone else. This cycle can spread compassion and happiness through a community.

      Delete
    3. Thanks for the comments! Grace, I like what you said about happiness being inward and outward. Our happiness has to do with ourselves but it is also intrinsically bound to others. Not just how others act towards us, but how we act to them. Ally, I think generosity is a cycle as well. Being kind to someone can really go a long way and might inspire others to be kind too.

      Delete
  25. Quote:

    "A major implication of Mencian philosophy is that education through indoctrination, without moral example and personal reflection, is ineffective."

    The above quote is saying that learning without questioning what you are learning, without analyzing what you are learning, and without having examples of what you are learning does not work. It's one of the reasons why you're supposed to ask questions in class, why you're supposed to come to tutorial. I've often found myself in the situation of going to tutorial to ask WHY something is the way it is, even though I'm only required to know the WHAT and HOW. But why do I ask WHY? Because it helps me retain what I've learned. I want to have a complete picture of something. Geshe Dadul-Le even said today that ignorance detracts from happiness. Isn't not knowing the complete picture ignorance? Wouldn't it be miss-knowing something? I'm almost 100% certain that Mencius would agree with Bhudda on these questions, because doesn't ineffective education leave one ignorant in any given area?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with the majority of your statement, but your statement on ineffective education had me thinking: wouldn't every type of education be ineffective? Think about it in the perspective of social studies classes: In the United States, you are taught about the Boston Massacre and how it was this big deal where British soldiers killed innocent civilians for disobeying, but in the UK, it's not called the Boston Massacre and is instead called the Incident on King Street, which makes it seem more reasonable for the British to have fired at the disobeying citizens. Here, we have two different types of education and although they are in different countries, shouldn't both countries be teaching about both sides of the story and not just a one-sided story that keeps you thinking that the other country was actually the bad guy? I think that this type of teaching method leaves a form of ignorance to the students. Yes, this is the same way we've been teaching Social Studies for who knows how long, but don't you think that education should be taught in a more complete manner, where we get all sides of events, and not just one sided view of things?

      Delete
  26. Question:

    Is Buddhism a philosophy or a religion?

    I'm pretty sure that Buddhism is a philosophy, but there are always things that I've come across which tell me that it's a religion. For example: Geshe Dadul-Le is a resident monk at a Buddhist temple. A monk screams religion. A temple screams religion. I've always thought of temples as places of worship to (a) divine being(s). (Does Buddhism have gods?) If it were a philosophy, my first instinct would be to call it a school. An example that points me towards philosophy: Geshe Dadul-Le never mentioned gods once during his talk. Nor did he even hint at the notion of an after-life. Could Buddhism possibly be a philosophy that takes the place of religion?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm thinking it's a philosophy. Buddhism is technically an atheistic perspective as they literally do not believe in a god or higher power. That would be a type of permanence, and Buddhists don't subscribe to that theory. As for their view of the afterlife, same thing. An after-life connotes an "ever after for eternity" kind of deal, but in Buddhism nothing is eternal. They are monks in the sense that they live strictly by a certain ideal and devote their lives to it, and their temple is, like you said, sort of a school. They go there to think and to learn and to be. But everyone worships something, even if that something isn't divine. If you define religion as a type of worship, I think Buddhists worship virtuous humanness, and though that's not anything divine, it could be considered a religion.

      Delete
    2. Serena, I agree with you on a lot of that, but I think most consider Buddhism a religion. Although Buddhism doesn't have any gods, this does not keep it from being a religion, cause religion doesn't just mean believing in a higher power. Buddhism has many qualities that make it a religion like rituals and a community aspect and a set of moral codes. Buddhists also worship Buddha, in a way. And I'm pretty sure they pray, too. It may not be what one typically imagines as religion, but I think it still is one.

      Delete
  27. I am still confused about how living virtuously and selflessly can be done to bring about happiness, when the search for happiness is all about selfishness. How can a person claim to be living virtuously, when everything they are doing is for themselves, not for others? This question is very complex, and there are many different possible solutions to it. I suppose that some people truly do virtuous things for the betterment of others, instead of the betterment of themselves. But Confucius' teachings said that living virtuously would bring about happiness. So if a person was only living virtuously to bring about their own happiness, how could they possibly be living virtuously at all?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was stuck in the same fix as you on this topic. But after the class discussion yesterday, the Buddhism reading last night, and the guest speaker today, I've come to think of the act of happiness becoming selfless like the act of meditating:

      1) One needs to clear impure intentions and mentla hindrances from the mind in order to achieve bliss
      2) Mental activities disappear, and all that's left is bliss.
      3)bliss begins to disappear
      4)all sensations are non-existent, and total peace of mind is achieved.

      This is kind of like a domino-effect, because you need to work towards one thing (pushing over the first domino), and then all the other things will start to happen, if if done correctly (if the dominoes are set up in a way to achieve the domino effect). In teh same way, one needs to have everything set up in such a way so as to achieve happiness:

      1) one has to do good deeds for other people. intentions do not matter (in my opinion)
      2)after getting used to doing these good deeds, one starts to realize the right intentions DO matter
      3)One starts to do good things purely for the sake of its righteousness

      Granted, these things will only fall into place if done correctly, so most people will not be able to achieve this version of ahppiness. I hope this helps to answer your question

      Delete
    2. I agree that it would be hard to start out searching for happiness, then go by Confucius' teachings which say you should forget all about searching for happiness, and just do things for the good of others. I agree that there are some people who are fully capable of just doing things for other people, and not for their own good. I still think that it's difficult to teach yourself to be this way if you aren't naturally. I think developing different intentions (doing things solely for others) for the sake of your original intention (happiness) doesn't really make sense. That is, if I'm even making sense. I think it would just be very hard to forget about your original intention. After all, wouldn't your goal still be the same?

      Delete
    3. I also struggled with this question. I think being able to do selfless actions solely out of the good of your heart is as big of a feat as achieving happiness. Personally, I'm not sure if living a virtuous life would make me happy. Maybe Confucius is saying that happiness is equivalent to living virtuously and by living virtuously and not focusing on yourself, you will end up happy. It seems like it would be really hard to train yourself to live a naturally virtuous life instead of living one just so you can be happy. Is the desire to live a virtuous life solely out of the good of your heart something that you are born with? I'm not sure how you can develop that state of mind unless you are getting something out of living virtuously.

      Delete
  28. "Learning about “humanity”, and trying to realize it in our lives, especially in the company of fellow travellers on the great path or Dao, fills us with a sense of joy."

    While learning about Buddhism, we always seem to hit the topic of serenity and getting rid of the negativity around us. Although not explained in the article nor the book, the saying "one with everything in the world" is tossed around a lot in Buddhism. What this quote above explains to me is that learning about humanity, in itself, should bring about great joy to us. In order for us to become "one with everything", we must first uncover the concept of humanity and what it means. But, in order to become one with everything, would we first have to know about everything, which in itself also means that Buddhists know everything there is to know about humanity? Sorry if it doesn't make sense; it does to me.

    ReplyDelete
  29. In class, we talked about how "ritual without humanity is empty," and what this truly means in regards to Confucius. I think that this is something that definitely applies today, because like we were talking about with community service, you can do something ritually, way more times than others, but if you do it without the right intention, it's meaningless. So does this mean that performing good acts even if they aren't on a regular basis would be better than doing them all the time and not meaning it? I think that "There is no greater joy than to reflect on ourselves and become sincere. There is nothing closer to humanity than to vigorously practice consideration for others" is also very relevant. While focusing on ourselves in order to become sincere will bring joy, it can't do so without us first being considerate of others, so that we may learn this sincerity. I think that while we may begin doing something for the sake of hoping it will make us happy, we will eventually forget about this once we become sincere in our intent to do this, and will focus on the action itself and the joy that we are bringing other people. I wonder if, in Buddhism, is it more important to practice refraining from harm in order to achieve happiness? The monk really emphasized harmlessness and how steering clear from doing certain things would bring happiness.

    ReplyDelete
  30. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Question: So, according to Buddhism, is TRUE happiness able to be achieved in this world?

    Buddhists seem to have "everything" figured out in a sense that they dump out the negativity in their world and only focus on the positivity in their lives. As Geshe Dadul-Le explained to us, in order to find an answer to happiness and to be happy, we must first take a journey within ourselves to become a more positive person and to learn how to control our feelings and how to react to events in our lives, small or large. This task, in itself, would seem to take forever, seeing as how our society has learned to react to everything with actions (more often than not, bad actions), that result in us leading astray from happiness. So, although monks and followers of Buddhism have become one with everything and have learned to be "happy", are they truly happy, or like Aristotle explains towards the time of his death, is this considered "Secondary Happiness?"

    ReplyDelete
  32. Question: Would Confucius like modern society and the way it operates or not? I'm a little confused about that.

    ReplyDelete
  33. "There is no greater joy than to reflect on ourselves and become sincere"

    Really embodies Mencius' teachings and illustrates how the only person in charge of how we live is ourselves. Through reflection we can further analyze our lives and the choices we make, refining them an infinite amount of times until we feel we have gotton things right, per say. Although there is always room for improvement, reflection helps us better understand ourselves and the specific choices we make. This quote really depicts that about the human nature of reflection.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with your thinking. By further looking at our mistakes, reevaluating on them, and improving on them over time, we can then reach a point in time where we will be able to do things "perfectly." By repeatedly doing this for everything, such as sports, homework, games, etc., we can eventually have a someone "perfect" unity with our body and can therefore reach happiness, in a sense.

      Delete
    2. I completely agree with you, Kyle. I feel that you could always improve yourself by contemplation and through finding yourself, you ultimately find happiness. Great pleasure and contentment always comes with knowing your relationship with yourself and others. ---- Taylor Bradley

      Delete
  34. The speaker today defined ignorance as "misknowing things." Essentially, when you call someone ignorant, you're not saying they don't know anything, but that what they think they know isn't an actual fact. Aristotle was quoted as saying he only knows that he knows nothing. By acknowledging this, he believes it made him a wiser than all those around him because he realized he had more to learn. This is somewhat of a response to Emma's statement above in which she said that only we can decide if we're happy or not. What if we are just ignorant to our own happiness or lack of it? Someone could be perfectly happy with what they have, and see others being happy with having something completely different. I think it's human nature to compare ourselves with others, and usually the "odd person out" feels like suddenly they need to change. They thought they were happy, but then they saw they weren't happy in the same way as others, so it must mean they're unhappy. Even though nobody was telling them they were or weren't happy. I have to agree with the speaker today that ignorance is one of the main reasons people aren't happy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you make a really good point. Sometimes we compare our own lives to others' lives, and in comparison, sometimes we feel as if we don't measure up. Demeaning your own happiness because someone else appears to have a better life than your own, while it is human nature, is not the right reaction. We cannot determine our own happiness by comparing our lives to others.

      Delete