If you posted in Al-Ghazali you are not forced to for the Enlightenment as long as you hit your week's requirements. If you were more moved by the Enlightenment, here you go.
I like the Utilitarian movement that began to form during the Enlightenment. This time period found people who believed that happiness can be found on Earth and that all could obtain it. In our class discussion about governement offering ways to obtain happiness, we all seemed to agree with the idea of this time period of the greater good. We differed when it came to the amount of governement interference. I believe that we all know that happiness is something all should enjoy but not all may be able to due to various handicaps. Unfortunately, it is easy for mankind to only care for themselves and their environment therefore government has to step in to help.
I agree that governments are right to concern themselves with the happiness of its citizens. However, I believe this only applies to a degree. Governments are moral to provide services to certain people such as food stamps, etc. to help assist in people's happiness. I think that more of this should come from the individuals within a society though, to help each other find happiness. When certain governments interfere too much, the result isn't pretty. In English today we discussed North Korea, and it is obvious that its citizens who know the truth about the communist form of their government are generally not happy about it.
I think the application of the gov't philosophy often matters more than the actual philosophy. An evil president can make life much more miserable for someone than a benevolent dictator or communist. North Korea is messed up, but look at Denmanrk/Sweden/Norway, countries that border on communist and have sky high happiness ratings.
Should the gov't just guarantee the necessities for survival - food, shelter, education, etc.?
I really do like a lot of the new enlightenment ideals. In many ways the entire enlightenment outlook is far more optimistic than really ANYTHING that had come before. Sure, I can be a cynic in many ways, but I do believe earthly happiness is attainable, and that as we humans we are capable of achieving it ourselves. As a result, many of these ideals speak to me. That being said, I do still hold a few areas of disagreement. I like humans, but I do not believe we are born "perfect" (the Locke, clean slate idea). There is something so innately competitive about us, this need to survive...everything is focused on us essentially and we are often willing to become violent to ensure our own needs are met. That being said, although I initially loved all of Hobbes's ideas about relativity...I'm a big fan of that concept, but his solution makes no sense given everything he had previously said...why do we follow whatever this leader says...what makes whatever he says "right"? If everything is relative, then maybe he is in the wrong and we shouldn't listen to him. Finally, Bentham's utilitarianism works well in theory, but simply doesn't come across as practical in the end. There are too many cases where a cold, clinical numerical analysis simply couldn't work...life just can't be reduced to that level of simplicity. I do believe the government has a certain amount of responsibility to see that people's basic needs are met (not necessarily their happiness). There is a balance to these things though. They cannot just be done by numbers. So yeah...my ramblings...tell me what you think. In short, I don't fully agree with anyone. I have yet to here a philosophy I fully agree with, but all three make some good points. Remember: Balance and Shades of Grey.
William, I totally agree with what you are saying. At first I really liked what Hobbes was saying about relativism. This does kind of makes sense to me, considering I think that most everything (including truth) is relative. However his way of going about happiness was ridiculous and cynical. In my opinion, happiness can never be the fulfillment of meaningless desires. Even if everything is relative, I think that we can attain earthly happiness from learning to help others and not thinking about ourselves. I also agree with your assessment of utilitarianism. it sounds good on paper but its just wildly unrealistic in practice. Literally every decision would be some kind of moral dilemna, and nothing would ever get done. In the context of government, it also brings up questions such as how does the government know whats best for me? Why do they get to decide what the greater good is?
Joey, in a bit of irony, you belief that truth is relative is well...relative. I think truth is an absolute and that it actually exists out there like "goodness."
Hobbes - have an absolutist to provide just enough structure so that everyone can do whatever they want.
I agree with you Will, i strongly support the idea of balance and shades of grey because no one size will ever fit all. I think that government is needed, but there are places were our government crosses the line. I also don't entirely agree with one person, but i think in this day in age we are accustomed to having our cake and eating it too. (aka we find it hard to believe in what just but one person says)
I like the Utilitarian movement that began to form during the Enlightenment. This time period found people who believed that happiness can be found on Earth and that all could obtain it. In our class discussion about governement offering ways to obtain happiness, we all seemed to agree with the idea of this time period of the greater good. We differed when it came to the amount of governement interference. I believe that we all know that happiness is something all should enjoy but not all may be able to due to various handicaps. Unfortunately, it is easy for mankind to only care for themselves and their environment therefore government has to step in to help.
ReplyDeleteI agree that governments are right to concern themselves with the happiness of its citizens. However, I believe this only applies to a degree. Governments are moral to provide services to certain people such as food stamps, etc. to help assist in people's happiness. I think that more of this should come from the individuals within a society though, to help each other find happiness. When certain governments interfere too much, the result isn't pretty. In English today we discussed North Korea, and it is obvious that its citizens who know the truth about the communist form of their government are generally not happy about it.
DeleteI think the application of the gov't philosophy often matters more than the actual philosophy. An evil president can make life much more miserable for someone than a benevolent dictator or communist. North Korea is messed up, but look at Denmanrk/Sweden/Norway, countries that border on communist and have sky high happiness ratings.
DeleteShould the gov't just guarantee the necessities for survival - food, shelter, education, etc.?
I really do like a lot of the new enlightenment ideals. In many ways the entire enlightenment outlook is far more optimistic than really ANYTHING that had come before. Sure, I can be a cynic in many ways, but I do believe earthly happiness is attainable, and that as we humans we are capable of achieving it ourselves. As a result, many of these ideals speak to me. That being said, I do still hold a few areas of disagreement. I like humans, but I do not believe we are born "perfect" (the Locke, clean slate idea). There is something so innately competitive about us, this need to survive...everything is focused on us essentially and we are often willing to become violent to ensure our own needs are met. That being said, although I initially loved all of Hobbes's ideas about relativity...I'm a big fan of that concept, but his solution makes no sense given everything he had previously said...why do we follow whatever this leader says...what makes whatever he says "right"? If everything is relative, then maybe he is in the wrong and we shouldn't listen to him. Finally, Bentham's utilitarianism works well in theory, but simply doesn't come across as practical in the end. There are too many cases where a cold, clinical numerical analysis simply couldn't work...life just can't be reduced to that level of simplicity. I do believe the government has a certain amount of responsibility to see that people's basic needs are met (not necessarily their happiness). There is a balance to these things though. They cannot just be done by numbers. So yeah...my ramblings...tell me what you think. In short, I don't fully agree with anyone. I have yet to here a philosophy I fully agree with, but all three make some good points. Remember: Balance and Shades of Grey.
ReplyDeleteWilliam, I totally agree with what you are saying. At first I really liked what Hobbes was saying about relativism. This does kind of makes sense to me, considering I think that most everything (including truth) is relative. However his way of going about happiness was ridiculous and cynical. In my opinion, happiness can never be the fulfillment of meaningless desires. Even if everything is relative, I think that we can attain earthly happiness from learning to help others and not thinking about ourselves.
DeleteI also agree with your assessment of utilitarianism. it sounds good on paper but its just wildly unrealistic in practice. Literally every decision would be some kind of moral dilemna, and nothing would ever get done. In the context of government, it also brings up questions such as how does the government know whats best for me? Why do they get to decide what the greater good is?
Joey, in a bit of irony, you belief that truth is relative is well...relative. I think truth is an absolute and that it actually exists out there like "goodness."
DeleteHobbes - have an absolutist to provide just enough structure so that everyone can do whatever they want.
I agree with you Will, i strongly support the idea of balance and shades of grey because no one size will ever fit all. I think that government is needed, but there are places were our government crosses the line. I also don't entirely agree with one person, but i think in this day in age we are accustomed to having our cake and eating it too. (aka we find it hard to believe in what just but one person says)
ReplyDelete