Sunday, January 12, 2014

Week #4 - Islam, Transition to Modern Philosophy

You can also follow up with Coveny comments.

91 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "He who knows himself is truely happy." (Al-Ghazali).
    This quote sums up al-Ghazali's idea of what would bring true happiness, as well as satisfy man's purpose for being created. Al-Ghazali believed that knowing one's self completely would lead to a personal, living experience with God. This is what drove him to leave his old life behind to search for himself and, by extension, his purpose. This idea of finding one's self being the key to finding happiness, as well as, being the purpose of our creation intrigued me. It made me think that he believed that finding happiness is the meaning of our lives. Therefore, the pursuit of happiness is, in fact, the pursuit of our lives' purposes. For me, this idea opens new possibilities for what the definition of happiness really is. I like the idea that finding happiness/working towards happiness is a righteous enough quest to also be considered the quest for our life's meaning.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have a cart vs. horse question:

      Does Al-Ghazali think the quest for self knowledge is righteous enough to undertake and the result is happiness or is it actually a selfish quest for happiness? I am thinking about the drunken walnut story at the end of the text. I am not sure.

      Delete
    2. To me it came across as a selfish quest for happiness at first. However, if it is in fact the reason that we were created it is no longer selfish. It is not selfish because you are doing it because it is what God made us to do. We are not doing it for the more shallow reason of finding happiness for ourselves. Since it is not a selfish quest I think that Al-Ghazali is saying that it is righteous enough.

      Delete
  3. In the reading there is a lot of talk about finding one's self. Al-Ghazali says that "self-knowledge is not to be attained by mere thinking or philosophy" but instead through religious things such as whirling dervishes and music. Personally I think that self knowledge comes from experiences, as well as, inward reflection and consideration of personal, philosophical beliefs. However, I am curious as to what you, my class mates believe. I would like to know if you have a different view on this topic. Are your beliefs more in line with Al-Ghazali's ideas, mine, or do you have a different idea all together?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Experience is the chisel which molds our ignorant and flawed marble block into the statue that it is today. If we try to carve stone with a toothpick or a cloth, the same statue may not come to be however, there will be a statue. There will be something. Experience may be the easiest way to shape ones being, but those who are shaped by other thing scan be just as fantastic. At one point, pure cubes were considered beautiful.

      Delete
    2. Experience is the chisel, but a very ugly statue can be made. To make a more beautiful statue, you need to take the ugly one, contemplate about what pieces of marble can be removed, and then actively remove those pieces with a chisel.

      Delete
    3. I agree with Frank. One can have experiences that may lead you to think that these decisions you are making will ultimately make you happy, but in the end, you'll just end up disappointing yourself by seeing what the outcome is. Of course, if the outcome is bad, you can always have the option to try and live with it and make the most of it, which in a sense that "ugly" experience could become one that would help you learn from your mistakes and help you create a more "beautiful" happiness.

      Delete
    4. To paraphrase Michelangelo a bit, he believed that the stone already contained "the statue" and he just had to discover it. Are our lives the same way? Can we really control the chisel?

      Delete
  4. in the reading, it said that Al-Ghazali emphasizes that few people have attained this supreme happiness and that these people are the prophets. Do you think the same applies to Christianity? and that only our prophets are the only ones who have attained and can attain this supreme happiness?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What is the Islamic view of Christian and Jewish prophets and their authenticity? There lies your answer.

      Delete
    2. I think it's really interesting that AG pointed out the prophets as the happiest people, as in most cultures, especially Christianity, prophets had terrible, terrible lives on Earth, but we must put this in context. Regarding the Islamic view of Christian and Jewish prophets, Muslims believe that they are false prophets and that the one true prophet is Muhammad. Therefore, is the prophet Muhammed the one and only true attainer of happiness?

      Delete
    3. Christians believed that the "supreme happiness" was obtained through humans' physical deaths and entering the after life. So this leads me to believe that Christians thought that the supreme happiness could only be achieved by those who had gone to heaven.

      Delete
    4. Two questions:
      False prophets or prophets whose messages were misinterpreted? I was under the impression that Islam respected the fellow monotheistic faiths theologically-speaking.

      2. Those prophets of Christianity/Judaism probably made it to heaven -- score one for ultimate happiness!

      Delete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Al-Ghazali focuses greatly on the idea of giving up selfish desires to experience true happiness. My mind immediately jumps to true and idealized love. Although rarely obtainable, it seems as though a perfect love (one that does not rely heavily on Physical intimacy) could be the answer to the happiness question. If you loved someone so much that you would give your entire being for them in a single heartbeat, could you truly be happy? Flash back to the rare old couple that you see, both smiling ear to ear when around one another. Could their peace and serenity be true happiness on earth? A love so pure and crystalline that the very desire of physical pleasure could not shatter it. This i do believe could be Happiness, for those who lose these people often imagine they will seek them out in heaven. Their love is so strong, that the idea of reuniting with their lost love one becomes their description of heaven. That is powerful.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Always with the love...

      Did the old couple start off with that intimate "pure" love or perhaps a more passionate physical attraction?

      What about Platonic relationships (in the Plato sense and not our current definition)?

      BTW, having known several of these old couples that serenity is also accompanied bitter debates over stevia packets, Dancing with the Stars and Kelly Ripa.

      In any case, I think your idea is an intriguing one worth debating and valid in that sense. I think you may be putting words in Al-Ghazali's mouth as well.

      Delete
    2. I think you make an interesting connection here, Jack. And I actually really like your comparison. Selfish desires could be compared to being in a relationship where you only want something for yourself, like physical intimacy or physical pleasure. However, "true love" could be compared to true happiness. You no longer want things just for yourself; you're focusing on someone else and their happiness.
      I don't think Al-Ghazali really touched on this subject, but I think you definitely make a good comparison between happiness and love.

      Delete
    3. I like it as well, but I think most of the "pure" love relationships often start off as something less than pure. Like the Platonic/Buddhist ascension of contemplation, you need to start just a little outside of yourself and slowly move on to the bigger and better.

      Delete
  7. Al-Ghazali says that one may truly be happy through "discovering through personal experience one's identity".

    The way that Al-Ghazali says this almost implies that by living our life for self exploration is the key to Happiness. If you live your life and learn from your experiences you may become Happy because you will truly understand yourself. This seems to simple. Could he be implying that once you know yourself you must act on the information you have to make yourself happy? Is the idea that Happiness will float down to you after you understand who you are? Is this just self contentment? IS LIFE REALLY THAT SIMPLE!!! Agh!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nope, it isn't. Al-Ghazali says you need to know your identity by polishing away desire etc. through contemplation etc. and then opening yourself up to communing with God through contemplation and physical acts like dancing. As you progress you will experience higher and higher forms of happiness that ultimately end with ecstatic union with Allah.

      Delete
    2. So literally an ascension to ecstasy?

      Delete
  8. Question: According to Al-Ghazali, is supreme happiness possible to achieve in this world without being a prophet ordained by God? Even if one lives a perfectly virtuous life, if God does not give you the gift of prophecy then you cannot be truly happy. This sounds just like the Homeric version of how luck, or being blessed by the gods can grant one happiness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Do you think Al-Ghazali believes you "earn" prophet status or are "given" prophet status? Just curious.

      Delete
    2. I don't think I can answer that question without a serious amount of research. From what I know about Biblical prophets, namely Old Testament, God specifically chose them to relay His message to the Israelites. God saw something about such a person that He saw as being worthy of the task of prophet and it usually differs. If I had to guess, I'd say Al-Ghazali believed that you are GIVEN a prophecy because God saw you as worthy.

      Delete
    3. I agree with Matt on AG's probable view of the prophets. I think most people view a prophet and being ordained at birth by God, not as someone who "became" a prophet, since most of the time prophets seem to be depicted as nearly perfect humans from the start. Although I'm sure the argument can be made for people who believe a prophet status can be achieved, I think the general consensus is that one is born a prophet and chosen by God before birth to be so.

      Delete
  9. I, personally, love al-Ghazali's philosophy here. It seems to be a near-perfect combination of all the methods of happiness we've looked at so far. It's got the Aristotelian aspect of contemplation (self-knowledge, AG calls it), the difference between ultimate happiness (AG's "ecstasy") and a secondary happiness which we can find in temporary quantities on Earth, the Buddhist concept of a middle way in which we should not depend solely on our physical desires and the first step to happiness is acceptance that we can change our ways, the modern Christian notion that it is a personal matter in which one must be introspective and know onesself to attain it, and the generally religious vibe that true happiness lies in a higher power and that our soulful selves are ever searching to attain that connection and knowledge. I also like that his publication is called The Alchemy of Happiness. Alchemy is a transformation of matter, usually to gold or a "universal elixir." I like that al-Ghazali equates the steps towards happiness to transforming our lives into something so precious. This Sufi philosopher gets two thumbs up from me!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Quote: "al-Ghazali writes that unhappiness is created by enslavement to desire and the belief that one should satisfy only one's desires". This is very similar to the beliefs of Epicureas and Zeno because al-Ghazali believes that the secondary happiness that everyone else who isn't a prophet of God can achieve is blocked by selfish, earthly desires. Also, his life experience sounds remarkably similar to that of the Buddha who also starts off in a comfortable position in society only to give it all up to seek further meaning in their life. The difference between them is that al-Ghazali wanted to help reform Islam, not necessarily start his own separate religion. The question arises of how much al-Gazali was influenced by the Greek philosophers and by the Buddha if at all?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is a tough question. There is a lot of evidence that al-Ghazali had access or at least "knowledge" of Greek philosophy however I don't know how much he studied it. The man was a genius Aquinas-type constantly reading and writing so my hunch is that he read at Aristotle and possibly Plato. I have no evidence that he had familiarity with Eastern traditions but I haven't dug super deep either.

      How many of the "great philosophers" have had similar experiences in life?

      Delete
  11. Quick question about the "leaving material possessions behind" thing. We've seen this done multiple times, through Buddha, ascetics, and now al-Ghazali. Adhering to al-Ghazali's Alchemy of Happiness philosophy, let's say I realize that material possessions are more obstacles than steps on the path to happiness. If I have this self-knowledge and am a prophet and do everything I can to achieve ecstasy, is it necessary to give up my material "wealth" or would I be brought to want to give up my possessions as I've found this ulterior level of happiness on earth without them?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hmmm...interesting question! What is more important, the realization of the unimportance of material things or the actual getting rid of them!?

      My vote says getting rid of. Think of hoarders...they know they shouldn't hold onto stuff, it is bad for them etc., but then again I do need that pizza box from last month...

      Others?

      Delete
    2. I think knowing and truly believing material wealth is unnecessary for happiness is enough for the Buddhists, ascetics, etc. to accept that a person could be happy. I say this because, to me, it doesn't matter what you have if you don't value it and it doesn't make a significant impact in who you are. For example, the material possessions lost their values with Prince Siddhartha, and he went on to found Buddhism. Even though he'd already emotionally abandoned his items, he went on to physically leave them too. What if he'd kept his house, and just used what he needed and rented the rest out? If you use something solely for its necessity and not use the extravagant features, would that not count as letting go? Because that item has lost it's possession of you?

      Delete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Al-Ghazali is known as the "Proof of Islam," a term I'm starting to question when faced with a lot of contradictory terms I don't understand. His writings and life practices may very well be in line with Islamic tradition, but when faced with his path to happiness, I'm confused. We're told that happiness is, in fact, attainable (through self-knowledge)-- except for the unhappy ascetic who has tried to increase his own devotion through prayer and reflection. So perhaps happiness is attainable in a different way than the ascetics' path? Al-Ghazali recommends self-knowledge as the true path, furthered by music and dance- but how can self-knowledge center around decreasing the boundaries of self? It places God in the center of one's life, yes, but "we lose consciousness of the self." So by losing ourselves, we learn about ourselves- which perhaps is just hard to understand next to my engrained Christian understanding of losing oneself to gain better understanding of a god, not of oneself.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I want to talk about this in class. It has lots of overlap with Buddhism and is an important concept.

      Delete
  14. Al-Ghazali claims that we are all "born with a knowing pain in the soul." We are ultimately lacking from the beginning. This seems to be a natural transition point into the upcoming modern idea of Hobbes that all men are born evil; we lack conscience or morality from the beginning. As the Christian tradition continues to claim that we were one perfect but, by our own fault, lost our perfection, is it possible that these ideas have spring from one another? Is it possible that the Christian concept of being born with original sin and lacking the perfection and grace we once had became so engrained in philosophical thought that other traditions start at a baseline of human lacking? I believe that it could. Christian philosophy was incredibly influential in the development of modern philosophy and could've served as a baseline for following traditions. What do you think?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And Christianity was influenced by Judaism...

      I think so. Great insight here and a good stepping off point for another class discussion.

      Delete
  15. one of the things that struck me while reading about Al-Ghazali, was read that he preached that,"every person is born with a knowing pain in the soul resulting from a disconnection from the Ultimate Reality." this sounds so similar to the Christianity view that every one is born with original sin, which is the ultimate disconnection with God and the garden of Eden. Looking at this connection, how could one reconnect with god an the ultimate reality. From a christian view point, i beleive there are two steps to do so. the first is to rid our selves of original sin through baptism. this will partially reconnedct us to God. the second step is to as Al-Ghazil says to get rid of finding our happy in earthly pleasures and find the pleasure in our knowing of ourselves. before original sin we where knowing of god but not ourselves. afterwards, we knew of ourselves and our nakedness, but not of God

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think Al-Ghazali also thinks communing with the divine through the loss of "self boundaries". dancing yourself clean so to speak.

      Delete
  16. "Self knowledge consists in realizing that we have a heart or spirit which is absolutely perfect, but which has been covered with dust by the accumulation of passions derived from the body and its animal nature."

    This quote is really interesting because it is strikingly similar to Buddhism, so much so that it seems al-Ghazali copied a Buddhist work word for word. In Buddhism, self-knowledge is a very fundamental part of who we are, and unless we make special effort to figuring it out and correcting it, we are hard-wired to have a "mis-knowledge" of who we really are. Buddhists believe that we have to take charge of our natural, human emotions, in order to then start focusing on studying ourselves. In this sense, emotions are like annoying noises that never go away while you're trying to study. If you block out the noises, you can then actually start to learn the material you're studying.

    Buddhists also identify "self" with our mind, body, and outside of our body. So, knowing our "self" = ascension to ecstasy = true happiness. What I mean by "ascension to ecstasy" is the act of rising out of one's bodily emotions, pains, and longings. Similarly according to al-Ghazali, supreme happiness is "the ecstasy of union with the divine." It is an out-of-body experience one has which unites them with God. God, I believe, IS happiness.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is also very, very Platonic in nature. The allegory of the cave has us incomplete with "mis-knowledge" etc...

      Delete
    2. I totally agree with you, Frank. I really like the way that al-Ghazali incorporates Buddhism in his philosophy. We really must know ourselves to have some sort of a foundation for our own happiness if we believe that happiness is inherently personal. It's within our control, so we must do what we can to figure out what the noises are and then block them out--or at least sift them out somewhat.
      Quick question: When you say that God is happiness, do you mean that God him/her/itself is the ultimate happiness, the only happiness, or do you mean that being united or at one with God is the happiness?

      Delete
    3. What I meant by saying God is Happiness is that what Christians perceive to be "God" is actually Happiness. I believe that there are two types of Happiness: worldly and Ultimate (Heavenly). In order to achieve worldly Happiness, one must incorporate God into one's life. I'm going to break with most Christian philosophers and say that this worldly Happiness is also perfect, along with Ultimate Happiness, though it is not quite Ultimate Happiness.

      But how can this be, you may ask?

      If you are a Christian, then it is safe to assume you believe God is perfect. It is also safe to assume you believe Jesus is a part of God, therefore making Him perfect, but also that Jesus was of this world. Therefore, if Jesus = God = Happiness, and Jesus = perfect, then Happiness = perfect, too. This means that all forms of Happiness are perfect, for two reasons:
      1) God is involved in both
      2) If one form is imperfect, then the entirety of Happiness is rendered imperfect

      Delete
    4. But couldn't a secondary form of happiness not be part of God? Even if Jesus was worldly, he wasn't an embodiment of worldly things like sin and temptation. Instead he was an extension of heavenly goodness placed into the world. So a secondary happiness, based in the world, doesn't have to be perfect because it never was a part of something perfect- that's reserved for the heavenly, less attainable, more perfect type.

      Delete
    5. That was Bentham like math there Frank!

      I like this discussion although it may be off topic. If something is of this world is it inherently flawed since it is not in heaven or heavenly?

      Catholics believe Jesus to be fully God (perfect) and fully human (most definitely imperfect). This is a tough one. Strangely, I don't think Jesus was always happy because he was fully human. He endured pain, suffered. Stoics don't "suffer," but Jesus did. Imperfection?

      Delete
  17. How did Al-Ghazali's philosophies influence the Islamic world/religion? Could it have brought God more closely related to happiness rather than Him just being a divine being whom peopole believe in because He is bigger than themseves? What was Islam like before Al-Ghazali came along? did it have emphasis on self-knowledge, or was it party hard, then go pray?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Paper topic?

      He was very influential in other arenas (law) but his "mysticism" along with Sufi faith would ultimately relegate him to lower status in the modern era.

      Delete
  18. "He who knows himself is truly happy."

    For me, this quote is difficult to understand. In Al-Ghazali's opinion this means that our soul is inherently pure and we must cleanse it of physical needs to get to know this pure being. However, I believe that this is very difficult if not impossible to accomplish. Cleansing ourselves of everything that has placed a mark on our soul is a very daunting task. In saying this, Al-Ghazali's creates a happy few like the Socratic philosopher kings.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Indeed, many times these things that he is asking us to eliminate are what shapes and makes us who we are. Why would these things, although granted some can be bad, have to be removed. I feel that this sense of self can provide us great happiness. Maybe he is referring to the cleansing of just the bad?

      Delete
    2. I agree with you Jack. A sense of self, like you said, bodes well for some, and may even be an agent through which they may achieve happiness. I think this idea of self-satisfaction, and being content with what you are can lead to one's happiness. Although now were are entering the realm of simply being content vs. true happiness, which some would not call "being content". To settle, or accept, to some would seem like a cop out to saying they have achieved happiness, but, having said that, some really DO find happiness in finally being content with oneself. It's relative, and I hate using that term so much in this class because it's overused, but it is. Anyways, I think AG's "happy few" really know themselves, but the majority of people merely aim to be CONTENT with themselves. If that makes sense.

      Delete
    3. That's a really cool idea Jack. I feel like those things on our mirror can definitely shape who we are sometimes.

      Also, Kyle, you make a really good point. I'm one of those people who believes a little bit more in being content than changing who you are. However, I think that maybe knowing ourselves in Al-Ghazali's view could lead us to being content with ourselves, so they might be different ways of expressing the same view. I think once you truly know yourself you can become content with yourself.

      Delete
  19. Why does laughing make us feel happy?

    In Mr. Coveny's presentation, he talked about how the Marist and himself believed in the power of laughter to bring us together and make us happier. In my opinion, laughing allows us to forget about the negative aspects of life and allows us to focus on the happy/funny things that surround us. I think that this even applies to the concept of fractional happiness. If we learn to laugh off some of our problems and worries, then we make a stride towards being happier people. For example: If someone experiences a lot of bad luck, and they learn to laugh at their tribulations because it is not in their control, then they can make the move to being happier.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you hit the nail on the head. You can look up all of the scientific data that says when we laugh we release some chemical in our body that makes us feel good. But from a psychological stand-point, laughing helps us to remove ourselves from the situation we could find ourselves in.

      Delete
    2. But laughter can also be a form of denial, which in and of itself is destructive to happiness. That's not to say that genuine laughter hurts (and it certainly releases the right kind of happiness-inducing chemicals), but I think to a certain extent only genuine laughter can truly help make us happier while forced laughter, used to cover up feelings or to pretend that we're something we're not, can only hurt us.

      Delete
    3. That's a good point about the chemicals Matt. I forgot about that.

      As for your response Beth, isn't fractional happiness almost a form of denial? Its denial in the sense that we are trying to keep ourselves from worrying about something that is stressing us out or bothering us, and at first I think we still worry about it. All we can do is tell ourselves it is not a problem until it finally does not become a problem. So if we keep laughing things off, but we still worry about them, eventually we will really not care about them. Denial is the first step in this practice.

      Delete
    4. I agree with will, allot of times, when we "laugh things off" we are using laughter to ignore and forget about a problem. i agree that most of the things that we do laugh off we can be out off our control, so there fore that kind of laughter is is just a step in the direction of a happy life of no worries

      Delete
    5. I think that in some cases laughter acts as a shield hiding your true emotions. Learning to laugh off your true emotions can help relieve stress and ultimately make us feel better; however, if a person is constantly laughing off what they truly feel, they may not get that sense of comfort after a long period of time. Where that line is crossed between being a happy person and finding humor in everything versus using laughter to shake off serious subjects, I don't know.

      Laughter between two people allows them to connect and grow together, which is powerful. With more laughter, people can connect on deeper and deeper levels, which is key in experiencing a sense of joy in this world. Through others, we experience this joy.

      Delete
    6. This is a good discussion!

      If you are no longer desiring something (fractional happiness) is it really denying that you want it? I don't want it anymore!

      Ask Mr. Murphy how often immature students laugh during his Holocaust class. It is frequent! Laughter is very much a defense mechanism!

      Laughing definitely brings people together when authentic. I love it!

      Delete
  20. 'The prophets of all times are the ones who have experienced this reality based on transforming themselves away from a self-centered to a God-centered existence."
    I feel like this theme kept coming up with the last few lectures and discussions we have had. Turning to God and emptying yourself to let God in seems to be a common way to reach happiness, but how are people supposed to completely empty themselves from everything except God? Last week, Mr. Ditzel said that the first step is to let go of things like money and materials, then to follow the Beatitudes. I'm pretty sure most people have trouble just letting go of materials and worldly pleasure, so how can humans realistically expect to find happiness with this path?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think that the letting go is more of a self evaluation. You have to evaluate what you find pleasure in. If you are focused on money and physical things like that, then you need to reevaluate what is important to you. I feel like it's less of a bad, empty thing and more of a good, new-life sort of thing.

      Delete
    2. I agree with Emma. In christianity, there are a lot of teachings about giving up your old life for a new one. Jesus asks his followers to basically leave everything behind and follow him. Also he literally died and was brought back to life, so I think it's safe to say that re-birth is pretty important.

      There's this really cool, strange concept in Buddhism called Anatta which means "no-self". The idea is that we are constantly changing so we don't really exist. While it might seem kind of far-out, I think it relates well to what we're talking about here. In life, we go through constant change, whether we notice it or not. So although it may seem like a really difficult task to completely "empty" ourselves and fill up the space with God, I think it's really just a change of self, which we do all the time. Granted, it is a pretty intense change.

      This is basically what Al-Ghazali is saying, I think. Give up your current self where you are just focused on you, and become someone else who is focused on others. Essentially what he is saying is… change.

      Delete
    3. We are constantly changing because we are being affected by those things surrounding us -- we are in union with the world.

      We are "I" because of self-identification and the identification from others (our causes, our parents).

      We aren't a "self" unless you believe it! Tell Descartes to shove it...

      Delete
  21. Why is humor so central to the Marist order? Moreover why does humor seem to be so rare within other orders? Humor does seem to lighten the mood in many serious situations. The fact that most orders are overly serious is what drives most people away, so I'm curious as to why they don't implement humor more? This somber attitude doesn't seem like a good marketing strategy.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. While I agree that it does not seen like a god marketing strategy, I think that other orders might not be as focused on humor because they have different goals than the Marists do. I think that the Marist priests have a personal goal to be more open, relatible, and less "preachy" than other priests. Because Marists are focused on more things than just the word of God and the spreading of the faith they can focus on more personal relationships and I think that this is what separates the Marists and makes them special.

      Delete
    2. I agree with Ryan - humor makes people seem more approachable and relatable, and I think Marist priests want to do just that. I personally think that humor is a huge part of being happy because it involves a positive attitude. There's a phrase that goes something like "you have to laugh to keep from crying", which I think is very true in some situations. Humor has the ability to find things in a negative situation, sort of like a relief from the seriousness of life. Even if you are not completely happy or are laughing to keep from being sad, studies prove that laughter and smiling makes your "brain happy". Simply by smiling, you can at least feel like you are happier or in a more positive, even if it is, temporarily, a false sense of happiness.

      Delete
    3. I agree with you completely. I think, however, that humans generally migrate towards the light-hearted things and humor. With that, I think religions emphasize human interactions and through these interactions humor comes out. People can connect easier and are attracted to humor, which comes directly through are interactions with others. I understand that through religion there are serious topics however that shouldn't be humorous, but I agree that there should be a more light-hearted approach to religion. This may make people more drawn to religion, and ultimately enjoy it more.

      Delete
  22. “the aim of moral discipline is to purify the heart from the rust of passion and resentment till, like a clear mirror, it reflects the light of God.”

    I think this quote embodies Al-Ghazali's writings. Although I feel as though this would not appeal to most people. Having god be the central point of one's life may not appeal to everyone. Of course, the most devout religious people will be willing to give up everything to try and reflect God, but the majority, I feel, will not want to eliminate everything they want and need to simply live for God. One can live for God, but while still allowing for the quenching of desires. Ghazali's quote is on point, I just feel it can be altered slightly the reflect and represent the majority a little more.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Al- Ghazali drives home the point that you have to know yourself before you enter a community. This is similar to Mr. Coveny's presentation and the Marist Way. Marist focuses on the community and coming together. This theme of togetherness comes directly from Jean Claude Colin's time. During his time, he wanted people to come together, which is still present now at Marist. This community and family formed at Marist is what Al-Ghazali talks about, yet Al- Ghazali says we need to focus on ourselves before we can be welcomed into a community. Where Marist differs is that Marist tries to form their students as God-loving, educated, and whole people through all our classes, retreats, and prayer services. The difference is Al-Ghazali says we need to lose ourselves in our community to find our true selves, but Marist doesn't allow its students to find themselves. Marist tries to form every student within our community; however, we are not given much leeway here at Marist to completely lose ourselves in our community here.

    I like Al-Ghazali's ideas. They aren't necessarily original and his own, but he takes ideas from other religions and philosophers and makes sense out of them. It's coherent and makes sense, and he made his concept of happiness more clear for the common man to understand.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think the way you put both ideas together in this is very well done, but I also really like how you mentioned that at Marist we don't have the leeway to completely loose ourselves. Do you think that has to do with the fact that Christianity focuses so much on finding yourself instead of loosing yourself?

      Delete
    2. How can we make Marist what it ought to be in your opinions?

      Delete
    3. submitted too soon...

      "while still remaining MARIST?"

      Delete
  24. "The oneness of oneself is likened to a perfect mirror which if polished would reveal one's true divine nature. The key to this polishing is the elimination of selfish desires and the adoption of a contrary to do what is right in all aspect's of one's life."

    It's strange to think that we are sometimes the ones who know ourselves the least. We can try to look in our metaphorical mirror, but most people's mirrors are sort of foggy. Self-criticism is definitely a factor that plays into our hazy views of ourselves. I feel like a lot of people probably tell themselves that they are not good enough or that they need to be a certain way to please others. Conversely, pride can make our mirrors foggy as well. If we believe we are always in the right, and we lose sight of our humility, we are seeing ourselves in a foggy mirror. Self-criticism and pride both, I feel, can cause unhappiness, and are both products of self-focus. When one focuses on himself, he is bound to feel some level of self-criticism or pride, or likely even both. However, If we were to clear up the fog on our mirrors, we would be able to see ourselves as we really are, which would eliminate those factors within ourselves that cause unhappiness. The key to doing this, according to the above quote, is to eliminate focus on self, and turn the focus towards others. I think what is "right", is working for the happiness and well-being of others. Through this work, we can clear up the fog on our mirrors, and achieve happiness.

    ReplyDelete
  25. How do Al-Ghazali's teachings connect with the teachings of Christianity or Judaism?

    Al-Ghazali was a Muslim, and Islam stems from the teachings of Christianity and Judaism, so it would make sense that some of Al-Ghazali's teachings would relate to the teachings of Christianity and Judaism. He taught that those who recognize that they are struggling, those who empty themselves for God's filling, will be the most blessed and happy. This connects strongly with early Christianity, because they believed in a very similar concept, that Mr. Ditzel talked about. Al-Ghazali also taught that by losing ourselves, we will find God. This makes sense, because once we empty ourselves and lose our individual identity, we can be filled with God, which ultimately leads to happiness.


    Al-Ghazali writes that "he who knows himself is truly happy." I think this pretty much sums up his teachings that we focused on. By letting go of who we are, we can gain a lot of self-knowledge. This self-knowledge is what Al-Ghazali claims to be true happiness.

    ReplyDelete
  26. In the reading, Al-Ghazali's core idea is said to be "that happiness consists in the transformation of the self." Similar the the quote that Serena brought up in class about the drop only being happy when it dies in the river, his core belief is about sacrificing your individual self for the community or greater being. In order to fully achieve happiness, one must first be selfless. This statement is similar the Marist way and its emphasis on community.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you look on the Marist webpage, directly after the Mission Statement, it says that the mission is achieved through the “COMMUNAL pursuit of excellence in academic, religious, extracurricular...”. I think you make a good connection here. Marist puts a large focus on a sense of community throughout the school in order to achieve success, just as Al-Ghazali emphasizes giving up individuality for community.

      Delete
    2. In our AP Lang class, our current unit theme is community, and we recently discussed MLK's "Letter from Birmingham Jail", in which he made the statement that the individual is more moral than the community. By this, he means that once in a community, people are often swayed by the decisions of the group. So really, communities can bring about negative effects on the individual.

      Delete
    3. If you think of the river metaphor again, that drop has no choice but to go with the flow of the river. It is powerless. I think Christian and Muslims and others would argue you just have to jump in the right river!

      Delete
  27. There is a quote in the reading about a "secret happiness." I was wondering what this kind of happiness was. Was is borrowed or did it originate in another philosophy like many of Al-Ghazali's other ideas or was it his own? I think it might be relating to the importance of community. To be a true part of the community, one must sacrifice themselves as an individual. When in a community, I assume that everyone works to find happiness for everyone. Is this secret happiness individual happiness while being within a group?

    ReplyDelete
  28. I'm currently reading a book called Lost in the cosmos.
    This book is a satire on self-help books but also on how ridiculous it is that we as humans know more about the cosmos and the universe than we do in our personal lives. and understanding ourselves.
    I feel that this statement is fairly accurate and is usually the case within society today. So i guess my question would be that as a culture, even though we are highly individualistic, have we lost ourselves? Can we strive to gain knowledge in ourselves rather than what's around us with our present culture?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really like what you are saying. I think that in this modern age we have tried so much to emulate others such as celebrities and other people we idolize that we have lost ourselves. However, I think this practice of blending into a surrounding group can be an o.k. thing in Al-Ghazali's view if we have found ourselves first because he believes we are part of something greater.

      Delete
    2. Heck, we would rather aimless and purposely surf the web than sit in silence with our own thoughts for more than 30 seconds. It is scary.

      Know thyself!

      Delete
  29. Is Al-Ghazali's philosophy understandable or is it too out-there for most to understand or apply to their lives?
    While a lot of his philosophy seems very concrete, much of it also brings in Sufism. I wonder if that important aspect of mysticism does not cause his philosophy to become less tangible and achievable for common people.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I feel like the way that Al-Ghazali incorporates all these different aspects from different philosophers makes it easier to understand and incorporate into our lives. Since we've already been experienced to the other philosophers, it is easier to digest and understand his view. I think the same applies to the people of the time as well. Like us, they had already been exposed to many of the aspects of his view, so it would not have been a huge leap away from the past views.

      Delete
    2. That's true. He definitely does a good job of combining a lot of the previous philosophies we've studied, and makes them easier to digest.

      Delete
    3. i think that Al-Ghazali did this on purpose. by taking the best of all the old teachings, he made it easier to find a path to happiness. by just studying his publishing, one could learn the many aspects of many ancient philosophers, without having to spend the time reading all their works. this is not only time saving, but is extremely helpful for those who did not have access to the works of all the other philosophers.

      Delete
    4. I think Al-Ghazali is trying to reach out to more people. The other philosophers tried to seclude their ways of being able to achieve happiness to certain people or certain groups of people. By combining a bit of everything, he was able to achieve a way of achieving happiness that would be accessible by many. As Conor stated, this also allows one to understand the basic principles for happiness that other philosophers have stated previously without having to look into them all that deeply.

      Delete
    5. then why does he finish things off with the dancing? His faith is the one part of the philosophy that is *arguably* the hardest part to connect with. I read him and I feel like saying "yes, yes, Yes, YES! wait a minute, dancing?".

      Delete
    6. Mr. Heintz, those were my thoughts exactly. He made everything really easy to understand and digestible, and then brings in the mystical aspect of his philosophy. It kind of disconnects the whole thing.

      Delete
  30. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  31. "In the Alchemy of Happiness, al-Ghazali begins by writing that “He who knows himself is truly happy.” Self-knowledge consists in realizing that we have a heart or spirit which is absolutely perfect, but which has been covered with dust by the accumulation of passions derived from the body and its animal nature. The essence of oneself is likened to a perfect mirror which if polished would reveal one’s true divine nature. The key to this polishing is the elimination of selfish desires and the adoption of a contrary desire to do what is right in all aspects of one’s life. As he writes, “the aim of moral discipline is to purify the heart from the rust of passion and resentment till, like a clear mirror, it reflects the light of God.”" I like this idea that it is possible to know yourself, but that al-Ghazli recognizes that it's a difficult thing to do. I like the idea that in order to find yourself you have to realize that it is possible to do so- I think commonly we think this is such difficult thing to do that we get too frustrated to do it. We see it as an impossibile achievement- knowing yourself is a hard thing to do. But, Al-Ghazali says that once we recognize we have something to find, it is just covered with our past mistakes. If we avoid selfish desires, we will be lead to finding our divine soul. Is this the same as ataraxia?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. What is your thought? Is it the same as ataraxia? Is finding ourself the same as avoiding selfish desires?

      Delete